topic Re: Bug when adding windows/doors on walls, the schedule in Archicad 25 double the walls in Project data & BIM

Bug when adding windows/doors on walls, the schedule in Archicad 25 double the walls

Alba — Wed, 28 Sep 2022 13:32:23 GMT

Hello,

When I am creating a schedule for measuring masonry on a project, Archicad 25 multiplies the walls that have windows or doors! When I measure these same walls for the exterior finishing, the information is correct either if I have windows or not. See below the example. Thank you!

(Imac with Monterey)

Re: Bug when adding windows/doors on walls, the schedule in Archicad 25 double the walls

Barry Kelly — Fri, 27 May 2022 01:34:11 GMT

Can you show screen shots of the schedule settings as well please?

Barry.

Re: Bug when adding windows/doors on walls, the schedule in Archicad 25 double the walls

Laszlo Nagy — Sat, 28 May 2022 20:47:13 GMT

And when you make those screenshots of the Scheme Settings Dialog, make sure both Criteria AND Schedule Field settings are visible.

Re: Bug when adding windows/doors on walls, the schedule in Archicad 25 double the walls

Alba — Sun, 29 May 2022 07:21:44 GMT

The schedule settings are below. I found out that if by chance the window/door is in front of another wall, and this one connects with our own window's wall, this one gets affected too. I added IDs to each wall so we can understand better what is correct or not.

Re: Bug when adding windows/doors on walls, the schedule in Archicad 25 double the walls

Barry Kelly — Mon, 30 May 2022 05:08:05 GMT

Try putting brackets around the materials.

Without them you are looking for all walls that are AAC Block and anything else that is Cement block.

Rather than any wall that is either AAC Block or Cement Bock.

There is a subtle difference.

Barry.

Re: Bug when adding windows/doors on walls, the schedule in Archicad 25 double the walls

Alba — Wed, 01 Jun 2022 12:19:51 GMT

Hi Barry,

tried it, but unfortunately didn't solved it.

Re: Bug when adding windows/doors on walls, the schedule in Archicad 25 double the walls

Miha Nahtigal — Wed, 01 Jun 2022 19:08:54 GMT

Check the schedule type - is it Elements or Components?

I had a problem with double beams when my schedule was under "Elements". When I moved it (created new one) under Components, it showed correct qties.

Re: Bug when adding windows/doors on walls, the schedule in Archicad 25 double the walls

Barry Kelly — Thu, 02 Jun 2022 01:56:26 GMT

@Miha Nahtigal wrote:

Check the schedule type - is it Elements or Components?

Yes that looks like what it might be.

@Alba , you appear to be doing a 'Surface' schedule, but you are asking for length, height and floor area.

That will be trying to calculate the front, back and edge surfaces.

Try an 'Element' schedule if you just want wall quantities or a 'Component' schedule if you want quantities of individual skins.

Barry.

Re: Bug when adding windows/doors on walls, the schedule in Archicad 25 double the walls

Alba — Wed, 15 Jun 2022 06:34:17 GMT

@Barry Kelly and @Miha Nahtigal

Thank you guys, that's exactly that! I moved the schedule from Surfaces to Components and now is giving me the correct quantities. Thank you! 🙂