topic Re: AC 23: Elements remain after their layer is deleted in Project data & BIM

AC 23: Elements remain after their layer is deleted

David Collins — Tue, 30 May 2023 10:35:35 GMT

I’m seeing some strange behavior in AC 23: Sometimes when I delete a layer the elements on that layer will remain visible in the floor plan. Highlighting one of these elements, its layer is noted as “missing” in the element settings menu and info box. Is this a bug or some new feature the logic of which completely escapes me?

Re: AC 23: Elements remain after their layer is deleted

Christophe Fortineau — Tue, 12 Nov 2019 10:45:19 GMT

Is this neither a bug nor some new feature. I am used to seeing this case since Archicad 18 (but probably before) when I modify the structure of a file by abruptly removing certain resources. An example: when I delete a material, all the resources using this material are not erased but show "missing". It is very likely that the visible element on the missing layer has undergone a similar action.

You can find the same "alert" with graphic overrides or layer sets.

Re: AC 23: Elements remain after their layer is deleted

Barry Kelly — Wed, 13 Nov 2019 01:12:25 GMT

David wrote:
I’m seeing some strange behavior in AC 23: Sometimes when I delete a layer the elements on that layer will remain visible in the floor plan. Highlighting one of these elements, its layer is noted as “missing” in the element settings menu and info box. Is this a bug or some new feature the logic of which completely escapes me?

This seems a little odd to me.
Usually when you delete a layer, then all elements on that layer will delete as well, so long as you use the 'Delete elements' option.
Otherwise you have the option to keep the elements and move them to another layer.

This is the same whether you delete the layer from the layer settings or the attribute manager.

Is that line part of a module by any chance or is this a teamwork file?

Barry.

Re: AC 23: Elements remain after their layer is deleted

Lingwisyer — Wed, 13 Nov 2019 01:39:10 GMT

Christophe wrote:
An example: when I delete a material, all the resources using this material are not erased but show "missing".

Layers have do not have the option to retain elements without changing their layer. Things like Materials and BMs on the other hand do.

Re: AC 23: Elements remain after their layer is deleted

Christophe Fortineau — Wed, 13 Nov 2019 14:42:45 GMT

Lingwisyer wrote:
Layers have do not have the option to retain elements without changing their layer.

Of course but it seems to be different into your file so I think there can be another way to make your layer missing. Like Barry said if your work with module or teamwork project...maybe you have an attribute conflict.

Re: AC 23: Elements remain after their layer is deleted

David Collins — Sat, 16 Nov 2019 07:57:26 GMT

Thanks to everyone for looking into this. My memory is a little hazy now, but I believe I made some changes to the layer structure on this drawing with the attribute manager and that might have scrambled things a bit. I’ll report back if I see this problem again.

Re: AC 23: Elements remain after their layer is deleted

Vicomte de Latouffe — Sun, 13 Feb 2022 12:31:00 GMT

Hi fellas,

does anybody have a conclusion on that? I am in the same case. I am trying to elements hosted in layers but they remain in the model after deletion within the layer "MISSING".

Re: AC 23: Elements remain after their layer is deleted

Barry Kelly — Mon, 14 Feb 2022 01:11:32 GMT

What Archicad version are you using?

How did you delete the layer?

Can you show an example of the element with 'missing' layer?

Barry.

Re: AC 23: Elements remain after their layer is deleted

Rafael Sangareau — Tue, 24 May 2022 08:10:01 GMT

Good morning, this problem is still not solved, the same thing happened in our office a couple of times with AC25, last one was yesterday, we delete the layer, select the delete elements option, the layer gets the deleted but all the elements remain with the layer as a missing attribute. It can be a really annoying thing because you have to scourge the whole file for them elements that you want deleted in a simple manner. There is a workaround, first select the move to other layer option to a temp layer and then delete the temp layer, but it shouldn't be like this. Cheers!

Re: AC 23: Elements remain after their layer is deleted

Barry Kelly — Tue, 24 May 2022 08:34:05 GMT

Something odd going on there.

So you are saying you can't just delete an 'original' layer because the elements remain in a 'missing' layer.

But you can delete the layer and move all elements to another 'temp' layer.

Then you can delete that 'temp' layer in just the same way that you tried to delete the 'original' layer and all of the elements delete as well.

If that is the case, I can't see what the difference would be.

I would be contacting your local support people and asking for help.

PS - does Find & Select searching for all elements with attributes missing help find them?

Barry.

Re: AC 23: Elements remain after their layer is deleted

Rafael Sangareau — Tue, 07 Jun 2022 09:51:48 GMT

Hi Barry, thank you for your reply, I haven't been able to replicate the problem yet, I'll try and find an older version of the file and see if it happens again. Cheers!