topic Re: New Wishlist items moderated in Our Community

New Wishlist items moderated

Pato99 — Fri, 04 Oct 2024 01:00:07 GMT

Hi, in the past I have spent hours creating wish list items with screen shots and edited images to get the point across.

Many of these wishes had upvotes and replies.

I feel like these have been undermined by being archived and not transferred to the new Wishlist at the discretion of GS team. I don't want to go too deep into this topic as there's already a thread Transfer-of-acknowledged-wishes-to-the-new-wish-list I've moved on and started adding in my wish listed items into the new pool.

My problem is, I just spent hours re-creating these wish threads only to have them moderated and edited by staff.

What was the crime.

"You posted 7 wishes recently, and in each one, you

posted links to all your other wishes, and
solicited users to like them and subscribe to them"

My intention was to alert people to my renewed wishlist items, all which were previously posted in the past but were starting again from scratch.

My thoughts were:

Adding links to each within will allow other users who like my wishes to easily find other withes I posted rather than being lost in the hundreds of wishes
By using the phrase "Please Like and subscribe" I was being facetious and it's unlikely to sway people either way
I wanted to drive interest by using excitable & friendly language to get people more involved, because if you haven't noticed upvoting is very slow even on the highly rated topics, only around 100 upvotes over many years.
I think without some sort of community backing barely any wished items will make the cut because it's unlikely many will make it above 10-20 votes. Not because they're bad ideas, only because there's not many voters.
Many wish listed items have workarounds now like Model View Options if you put a bit of elbow grease in which bogs down the list.

The moderator says it goes against policy. However I checked the guidelines and it says nothing of the sort.
Wishlist Guidelines does not state this, nor does Community Posting Guidelines

The Wishlist FAQ actually states the following, "Can I promote my wish on Graphisoft Community? A: Feel free to promote your wishes!"

**I added the links in this post because it wasn't against policy (Doesn't state anywhere that it's not allowed) but, Moderators again removed links from this thread to make a point and suit their narrative**

Re: New Wishlist items moderated

Laszlo Nagy — Fri, 04 Oct 2024 00:05:15 GMT

@Pato99 wrote:

The moderator says it goes against policy. However I checked the guidelines and it says nothing of the sort.
Wishlist Guidelines does not state this, nor does Community Posting Guidelines

The Wishlist FAQ actually states the following, "Can I promote my wish on Graphisoft Community? A: Feel free to promote your wishes!"

You left out a part from the FAQ:

"Feel free to promote your wishes! You can increase visibility by adding a link to your wish in your signature."

So, put those links in your signature. Then, if you are active on the forums, you will have many posts where people will see those links to your wishes.

Here is an example of user thesleepofreason who has several wish links in his signature:

https://community.graphisoft.com/t5/General-discussions/New-AC-Add-Ons-by-Bimdots/m-p/613196#M5313

Re: New Wishlist items moderated

Pato99 — Fri, 04 Oct 2024 00:49:55 GMT

Of course, because it's just an option of what you can do.

It's a new sentence. Doesn't say "Feel free to promote your wishes by putting them in your signature" or "Put you wishes in your signature if you want to promote them"

Re: New Wishlist items moderated

mthd — Fri, 04 Oct 2024 03:06:14 GMT

@Pato99, I found the first line in your signature to be quite applicable and funny too.

Re: New Wishlist items moderated

Pato99 — Fri, 04 Oct 2024 03:29:20 GMT

Hahahah I forgot about that! Too True!

Re: New Wishlist items moderated

Lingwisyer — Fri, 04 Oct 2024 08:06:41 GMT

100 votes over many years is probably due to the lack of visibility of anything on this forum. Unless you use saved shortcuts, even new posts in subs you are interested in are not very visible. The Wishlist being hidden under "Building Together" does not help either, even though that is the most valid place for it. Maybe if they got rid of the huge search banner, and all the Knowledge Base links on the side bar, there would be space for sub listings like you would find on any good forum.

Ling.

Re: New Wishlist items moderated

hevi — Fri, 04 Oct 2024 09:01:27 GMT

And now we have two different UIs for the wishlist and the roadmap... I get that the community platform limits the possibilities but for anyone wanting to increase user engagement the current setup should be unacceptable.

Wishes should be organised under main development topics not just casually labeled.

Wishes should be discussed with replies not just commented.

Wishes should be rated, just as roadmap items, not just "liked".

Re: New Wishlist items moderated

Lingwisyer — Fri, 04 Oct 2024 09:15:26 GMT

In memory of the old polls, who's data feels like something that has been lost to the void, yet apparently has not.

Re: New Wishlist items moderated

Pato99 — Wed, 09 Oct 2024 02:03:26 GMT

It's done guys, updated my Signature!! 😓