topic Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com in Libraries & objects

Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

Levente Filetoth — Wed, 18 Jul 2012 08:31:00 GMT

Dear Archi-Talkers,

I guess I am preaching to the choir when saying that GDL is one of the core assets of ArchiCAD. To provide support for great GDL content to get created we launched BIMcomponents.com with ArchiCAD 16. In order to give some boost to the interest for the topic we decided to help deliver some long wished GDL objects that no-one has created as of yet.

Here we call upon a little contest: share your wish for an object that you cannot find in the standard ArchiCAD library and we will see to it that some of them get programmed and shared with all of you through the BIMcomponents.com portal.

The rules are very simple, just make a post with a concise description of what you think could be solved with the help of GDL and your award is that if your idea turns out to be interesting enough it will be programed by a professional GDL developer.

Please give us your ideas and let's see if we can create some extra value to the ArchiCAD community with the help of GDL.

Disclaimer: This promotional activity's goal is to find objects that are over the line of standard object development project, hence will never make it to the standard ArchiCAD library. Please use this thread to provide your input to this specific topic and please avoid raising issues related to the development of the standard ArchiCAD object libraries and/or to the development of the GDL technology in general. Thank you for your understanding.

Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

Laszlo Nagy — Wed, 18 Jul 2012 15:15:32 GMT

As a moderator who reads every post and has done so in the last several years (so I have some kind of idea of what people wished for before), I am wishing on behalf of the ArchiCAD community for the Modular Joinery object to be available to all.

Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

vistasp — Wed, 18 Jul 2012 15:45:11 GMT

Plus one on that!

Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

Anonymous — Wed, 18 Jul 2012 16:25:13 GMT

Agree! Good one Laszlo.

Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

Karl Ottenstein — Wed, 18 Jul 2012 17:18:21 GMT

Wish: asymmetrical arch-topped windows and doors - that is where the shoulder height on one side does not match the shoulder on the other - and the radius is parametric.

Attached is an image with windows that cannot be modeled with the symmetric-only windows in the standard AC library. (These windows are not curtainwalls - but standard, mulled/ganged residential windows with standard interior / exterior casing/trim, etc.

Thanks,
Karl

Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

vistasp — Thu, 19 Jul 2012 04:13:43 GMT

I'd love to see a catenary arch join the existing arched openings.

Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

Achille Pavlidis — Thu, 19 Jul 2012 06:21:33 GMT

I would like to see the modular joinery as part of the standard library too.

Also I would like to have pocket sliding windows.

Also I would like to have pocket sliding shutters for the pocket sliding doors/windows.

Thanks Santa.

Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

RandyC — Thu, 19 Jul 2012 16:58:21 GMT

I would like to see a truss system that works like roofmaker wizard - or is this delving beyond Object creation.

Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

Laszlo Nagy — Thu, 19 Jul 2012 19:02:32 GMT

As far as I understand this thread is for wishing for individual objects you would like to have programmed in GDL.

Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

RandyC — Thu, 19 Jul 2012 23:56:02 GMT

maybe some API developers will read this forum

Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

JaredBanks — Mon, 23 Jul 2012 20:53:06 GMT

Improved Modular Joinery for 16 would be awesome! And asymmetrical arch tops too. Those forced me to learn how to make custom doors and windows!

Oh how about an improved/updated free form window object? The one we all have is from what, AC10 or earlier?

By the way, thanks for doing this. I think it's a great treat for the community. I hope it becomes a regular (yearly/quarterly?) occurrence!!!

Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

sinceV6 — Mon, 23 Jul 2012 23:10:10 GMT

The Modular Joinery would solve a lot of issues with the library objects. It might even simplify it, as I'm sure many would stop needing separate objects and use a single object/interface to solve a lot of doors and windows. Haven't used to object myself, but read about it... a lot!

In this regard, one object I would like is a "Modular railing object": Combine the available fences and railings into a single powerful object that is true 3D; I mean, one railing object that can have several segments and adapt to stair slope in 3D using editable hotspots, that gives control over post position per segment, etc.

A single object to avoid the need of 5 or more railing objects per stair and build it in segments, some horizontal, some sloped, check connections, etc... or use walls, beams, etc. to build them.

Olivier Dentan has a railing object close to this, with several segments, but it is constrained to a (x,y) plane.

I've been fiddling with this and I think is doable... but I lack the time.

Or is it that this has been done already and I missed it?!!?!

Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

JaredBanks — Mon, 23 Jul 2012 23:57:03 GMT

sinceV6, have you looked at CADswift's Swift Balustrade? It does exactly what you're asking for. I believe Kristian even has a trial version of the object.

http://cadswift.com.au/categories/CADswift-Shop/

Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

Anonymous — Tue, 24 Jul 2012 08:27:33 GMT

Parametric lumber that can be easily rotated and shows the "x" when cut.

Additional features that would be nice could include built in shaping like dove tailing the ends or notching or even built in hangers. Also being able to have a single lumber object represent more than one piece and have the hanger encompass all the pieces. Such as having a (3)2x10 beam with hangers that held all three pieces of lumber as a single object.

Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

Anonymous — Tue, 24 Jul 2012 08:50:16 GMT

http://www.objectsonline.com/product_info.php?products_id=1353

This is the Commercial Sink Designer object. I think this object should basically be in the library as is. Most commercial businesses I've done work for need commercial sinks and the base Archicad library doesn't really represent this properly. Also this isn't a niche item. It's pretty standard and weirdly lacking at least as far as the MEP goes.

Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

Barry Kelly — Tue, 24 Jul 2012 09:21:12 GMT

laszlonagy wrote:
As a moderator who reads every post and has done so in the last several years (so I have some kind of idea of what people wished for before), I am wishing on behalf of the ArchiCAD community for the Modular Joinery object to be available to all.

And with sliding window/door options added - not just hinged and fixed.

Barry.

Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

TMA_80 — Tue, 24 Jul 2012 10:53:31 GMT

I don't if this can be considered as an object:

A Zone that can be dispalyed in section and elevation ( color , informations)

Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

Laszlo Nagy — Tue, 24 Jul 2012 11:08:05 GMT

TMA_80 wrote:
I don't if this can be considered as an object:

A Zone that can be dispalyed in section and elevation ( color , informations)

I am not absolutely sure about this but I think this would require functionality ArchiCAD currently doesn't have.

Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

Aladar Kish — Tue, 24 Jul 2012 12:37:48 GMT

I agree with Laszlo - the Modular Joinery object
and Karl - asymmetric arch topped windows and doors

Re: Wish upon an Object from BIMcomponents.com

Anonymous — Tue, 24 Jul 2012 13:39:31 GMT

Zones wish - the functionality is already there as there is such a zone you can buy on line

Modular joinery and curved top window - already available from cadimage and others no doubt

What about something a bit more out there? We now have morphs and shells (from 15 on)....how about an object that 'clads' such objects - with user defined profiled members to form framing? This kind of thing is very easy in revit but very impossible in good old archicad...