topic Re: Using the"Wallhole" command. in Libraries & objects

Using the"Wallhole" command.

Anonymous — Wed, 24 May 2023 09:56:37 GMT

I'm trying to create a window with an arched top. In plan, I create a slab that has the desired shape, I give it an ID listing of "Wallhole", and I insert it into the wall using the "window" tool but I only get a rectangular opening without the desired arched top. Can anybody help me with this. Thanks.

Re: Using the"Wallhole" command.

Anonymous — Wed, 16 Sep 2009 16:34:08 GMT

Hi Jerome,

Did you simply change the ID of a slab is a part of the window?... or Have you modeled a separate slab for the wallhole and changed its ID?...

Re: Using the"Wallhole" command.

Anonymous — Wed, 16 Sep 2009 18:06:02 GMT

I modeled a separate slab and gave it an ID listing of "Wallhole." Is this correct?

Re: Using the"Wallhole" command.

Anonymous — Wed, 16 Sep 2009 18:28:40 GMT

I modeled a separate slab and gave it an ID listing of "Wallhole." Is this correct?

The ID must be just "Wallhole" not "Wallhole."... with no endpoint... Have you checked it?
HTH.

Re: Using the"Wallhole" command.

Karl Ottenstein — Wed, 16 Sep 2009 18:36:27 GMT

Jerome wrote:
I modeled a separate slab and gave it an ID listing of "Wallhole." Is this correct?

Yes. AC 9 and above only. I do not believe that it matters that you used a capital "W". But, I am guessing that when you selected your assembly (you did select ALL elements, including the wallhold slab, right?) - and saved it as a GDL object that when you selected 'window' as the object type, you may not have selected the 'Editable GDL Script' (or something like that - not running AC right now) radio button?

Cheers,
Karl

Re: Using the"Wallhole" command.

Anonymous — Wed, 16 Sep 2009 19:12:07 GMT

Thanks for you interest in this problem. Please let me state the way that I've been proceeding:

1. I create the window assemble in plan using the wall tool for the mullions and the slab tool for the glass.

2. I then create a separate all-encompassing slab that engulfs the above-mentioned elements (see attachment). This slab has the desired contour of the window opening and I give it an ID listing of "wallhole".

3. In the 3d window, I save the object (see attachment) with the File>GDL Objects>Save Project As command.

4. In the Save as Library Part dialog box, I save it as a window and I check the "Editable GDL Scrip" radio button.

5. I then insert it with the window tool and the desired arched top does not appear.

Re: Using the"Wallhole" command.

Anonymous — Wed, 16 Sep 2009 19:25:19 GMT

Hi Jerome,

You may have to do it at the Global zero centre (0, 0).

I think you can't see it because it will be outside the wall.

Regards,

Re: Using the"Wallhole" command.

Barry Kelly — Thu, 17 Sep 2009 01:48:37 GMT

I am not sure if this is related exactly to your problem but a similar (same?) thing happened to me just yesterday when I quickly showed someone how to create a custom window object.
I followed the same procedure as you and gave the slab an ID of "WALLHOLE".
Created the object and lo and behold it was a rectagular wallhole - not shaped.
I had a look at the script and the "WALLHOLE" command was there but right at the end of the 3D script.
I cut it out and pasted it back to the beginning just after the MUL and ADD commands.
Saved and all was well.
I was just doing this quickly and did not explore the problem any further.
This was probably the first custom window i have created in version 12.
I have never had problems with this in previous versions.
Barry.

Re: Using the"Wallhole" command.

Anonymous — Thu, 17 Sep 2009 11:59:45 GMT

Thanks for all of your responses (especially to Karl O. in Montana). I'm getting it to work now. Apparantly, this was the problem:

In the Save as Library Part dialogue box, I didn't check the "Editable GDL Script" radio button.

Jerome