topic Re: PLA Archive file library parts in Libraries & objects

PLA Archive file library parts

Tom Krowka — Wed, 01 May 2019 18:14:12 GMT

When saving to a .PLA archive file, one of the choices asks if one wants to "include all parts in...…" "Local libraries: Save all parts from all loaded libraries." .
Am not clear whether this means all parts from the libraries (which basically means copying the entire library) or if it simply means only saving the library parts that are included in the .PLN file.
Thanks Tom

Re: PLA Archive file library parts

Barry Kelly — Thu, 02 May 2019 01:13:51 GMT

Include all parts means literally all parts in you loaded libraries - the entire libraries.

If you don't tick that option you will get just the parts used in the file.
From memory this may miss some CALLED macros, I think it depends on how the objects are scripted.

Including all would be the best option if you think you will want to do further work on the file in the future or if it is for someone else to use.

Barry.

Re: PLA Archive file library parts

Tom Krowka — Thu, 02 May 2019 14:05:06 GMT

It seems to me it would be a smaller file to simply include parts that are used in the project. Upon opening the PLA file in the future migrate library’s from that appropriate version. Do you see a problem with that approach

Re: PLA Archive file library parts

Barry Kelly — Fri, 03 May 2019 01:36:39 GMT

Nope.
I think migration should be fine if you are using GS libraries.

If you are using a 3rd party library then I think it would be a good idea to include the whole thing - just in case you can no longer find it in 5 years when you re-open the file.

Actually I would ask the question do you really need to archive as a PLA at all?

Barry.

Re: PLA Archive file library parts

David Maudlin — Fri, 03 May 2019 11:33:15 GMT

Barry wrote:
Actually I would ask the question do you really need to archive as a PLA at all?

The archive can also save textures, so any project specific textures are also saved. I always archive my projects when putting them to rest.

David

Re: PLA Archive file library parts

Barry Kelly — Mon, 06 May 2019 01:42:44 GMT

David wrote:
The archive can also save textures, so any project specific textures are also saved. I always archive my projects when putting them to rest.

The textures are also found in a library.
So if you have access to that library then again I would question if the PLA is required.

You can also save these textures and project specific objects in the embedded library, so we basically have a built-in archive already.
The only real problem with this is if the embedded library starts to get very large, then it may slow the file down a bit.

Barry.

Re: PLA Archive file library parts

David Maudlin — Mon, 06 May 2019 11:57:38 GMT

Barry wrote:
The textures are also found in a library.
So if you have access to that library then again I would question if the PLA is required.

If the user has created, modified or downloaded a custom texture, or is using project specific libraries, then these textures will not be found in the standard ArchiCAD libraries (as well as any custom/non-standard library parts). Given the low-cost of storage, archiving projects is a safer choice.

David