topic Re: D1 20 USA 'Simple' detail level 'simply' wrong in Libraries & objects

D1 20 USA 'Simple' detail level 'simply' wrong

Ignacio Azpiazu — Wed, 24 May 2023 08:44:22 GMT

A 3 ft door shown with detailed, medium, and simple detail level. At 'simple', door opening takes over the jambs, door dimension and sweep get wider, opening dimension floats in space (these are 3/4" jambs —it would be more obvious with thicker ones, doors will bump into toilets, etc.). I would think this is not the way it should be, right?

Re: D1 20 USA 'Simple' detail level 'simply' wrong

Anonymous — Wed, 07 Mar 2018 01:41:42 GMT

Try setting the frame width to zero. Seemed to work for me. Not sure about the opening dimensions. It does seem kind of odd though that the standard library part wouldn't do this automatically. Maybe a small oversight on the author of the part.

Doug

Re: D1 20 USA 'Simple' detail level 'simply' wrong

Ignacio Azpiazu — Sat, 10 Mar 2018 20:20:24 GMT

Frame width to 0 will obviously not work in the medium and detailed views, where I want to see the frame. This is just a big screwup.

Re: D1 20 USA 'Simple' detail level 'simply' wrong

Daniel Kovacs — Wed, 28 Mar 2018 12:30:25 GMT

Dear Ignacio,

Actually, it works as it was designed to work. Our definition of a "simple view" was to have just the door opening and draw the arc in it (disregarding the frames completely). This usually is not a problem, as most people use this kind of representation at bigger scales, where the difference is negligible (1:200-1:500).

Still, I can totally understand what you mean, the arc won't match the arc of the real door like this. I have notified the designers about this. Thanks for the input.

Regards,