topic Re: ARCHICAD Doors don't Cut a wall hole consistently in Libraries & objects

ARCHICAD Doors don't Cut a wall hole consistently

Aaron Bourgoin — Wed, 24 May 2023 08:45:03 GMT

I've been having issues placing doors in AC21. The behaviour is inconsistent (AFAIK), but if anyone has a suggestion about the proper imaging of doors, I'd sure appreciate the assistance.

see screenshot attached.

Re: ARCHICAD Doors don't Cut a wall hole consistently

DGSketcher — Mon, 16 Oct 2017 21:04:54 GMT

Could be a number of things but I would first do a marquee cut and check the door position in 3D, check the home story and elevation heights and renovation status.

Re: ARCHICAD Doors don't Cut a wall hole consistently

Piotr Dobrowolski — Mon, 16 Oct 2017 21:29:27 GMT

This is probably the ugliest thingy... happening due to approved in the releases of AC 21/20 a "holy grail" (case intentional) of the "correct" "new" reno design phase 😜

Explanation:
In some of "out of the box" templates the default the reno phase is "new"...
and it causes a lot of problems when user switches to the view that does not include a "new" phase...in such case the phase automatically switches to "demolish"...and if the door set to "demolish" is placed inside a wall that is "new" - the wall can look like on the screenshot if the "default" reno filter is set.

So If I do not use the renovation in the project it is much safer to switch the default "existing" and if exported to IFC - set up the translator to make the exported elements as "new", than using the default "new".

If by any chance the "new" phase is mandatory - the reno palette is a must in the UI to constantly check if the phase did not accidentally switch...

Best Regards,
Piotr

Re: ARCHICAD Doors don't Cut a wall hole consistently

Aaron Bourgoin — Tue, 17 Oct 2017 14:48:56 GMT

Piotr!

Renovation status and all that's involved with that appears to be the issue.

GSHQ. This points out the need for consistency in the template files developed for every release. New features are great, too, and nothing short of amazing. But I will keep insisting that the template files be as bulletproof as possible.

Thanks for your help.