topic Re: Project2 for custom door plan in Libraries & objects

Project2 for custom door plan

Anonymous — Wed, 24 May 2023 08:47:45 GMT

is there a trick to using PROJECT2 for custom doors? the projection code only shows front or side views of the door in the plan preview.
I want to create a projected and symbolic option for my custom door, but project2 just isn't working.

Re: Project2 for custom door plan

David Maudlin — Wed, 09 Mar 2016 13:21:58 GMT

patmay81:

I get a correct result from:
PROJECT2 5, 90, 2
The "5" projection_code is not mentioned in the GDL Reference Guide (I guessed).

You should add a Signature to your Profile (click the Profile button near the top of this page) with your ArchiCAD version and operating system (see mine for an example) for more accurate help in this forum.

David

Re: Project2 for custom door plan

DGSketcher — Wed, 09 Mar 2016 17:59:54 GMT

David: "5" is not listed in the GDL manual and therefore I assume a risky option. Normal top view would be PROJECT2 3,270,2 is there some trick in using "5" ?

Obviously it is always better if the plan view is properly scripted to show the expected image e.g. door swing etc.

Re: Project2 for custom door plan

Anonymous — Wed, 09 Mar 2016 19:03:01 GMT

I had tried PROJECT2 5, 0, 2... but not 90, that was my problem. I was not thinking of it as actually rotating the 3d view to an alternate plane, just around its own plane. 5, 90, 2 works great. 3, 270, 2 also works, not sure of the advantage of one over the other.

I have two more questions:
1) any ideas on why my wall hole does not show up in 3d? I have scripted a wall hole as:
WALLHOLE 4, 2,
0, 0, 15,
A, 0, 15,
0, B, 15,
A, B, 15
but don't get an opening. See attached image.

2) why would the door offset from the wall hole hotspots in both 2d & 3d? I have tried including an ADDx line to both scripts and it has no affect. Seems like starting from 0, it should align w/ the door script, or do wall holes measure from centerline?

See attachments for more clarification

(I will get a signature line added to my profile; I don't often use this forum anymore, but may start up again, so I'll get up to speed)

Thanks

Re: Project2 for custom door plan

Anonymous — Wed, 09 Mar 2016 19:06:27 GMT

Image:

Re: Project2 for custom door plan

Laszlo Nagy — Wed, 09 Mar 2016 21:05:31 GMT

patmay81 wrote:
1) any ideas on why my wall hole does not show up in 3d? I have scripted a wall hole as:
WALLHOLE 4, 2,
0, 0, 15,
A, 0, 15,
0, B, 15,
A, B, 15
but don't get an opening. See attached image.

In the local coordinate system of the Door the 0, 0 coordinate is the middle bottom point of the Door. The Door extends both to left and right equally.
So the Wallhole definition show be like this:

WALLHOLE	5, 2,
			-A/2, 0, 15,
			A/2, 0, 15,
			A/2, B, 15,
			-A/2, B, 15,
			-A/2, 0, 15

It may be a better idea to close the polygon, thus the 5 nodes instead of the 4 (I am not totally sure about this, I just looked at the examples in the GDL guide.)
But an even important point is that when the WALLHOLE is rectangular, you do not have to specifically script it because the Door will automatically cut a rectangular hole for itself from the Wall by default. You need to script a Wallhole only if it is not rectangular.

This page contains some useful info about the creation of Doors/Windows:

http://gdl.graphisoft.com/gdl-docs/gdl-guide/chapter-12-miscellaneous/doors-and-windows/

Re: Project2 for custom door plan

Anonymous — Wed, 09 Mar 2016 21:49:45 GMT

Thanks Laszlo! I was referencing the link from the GDL center, but did not understand the door/window nature of originating from the center of the opening. So I think I need to rewrite the script to base off A/-A instead of 0,0/A.
I thought if I had a manual WALLHOLE I could offset the wall hole to match my script, but that doesn't translate well to the plan projection (back to the original question of PROJECT2{2}); unless I have a WALLHOLE2 also.

Re: Project2 for custom door plan

Anonymous — Wed, 09 Mar 2016 22:07:50 GMT

Ok, I think I found the easy solution. Just a simple:
ADDx -A/2 !at the top of the 3d script window

I had to modify my transformation stacks a bit, but everything is in the right spot now, plan and elevation!

Thanks for all the help everyone!

Re: Project2 for custom door plan

Gergely Feher — Thu, 10 Mar 2016 06:15:18 GMT

patmay81 wrote:
I was referencing the link from the GDL center, but did not understand the door/window nature of originating from the center of the opening.

Here is a short article about the basics of doors and windows: http://gdl.graphisoft.com/gdl-basics/simple-doors-and-windows/

I hope it helps.

Re: Project2 for custom door plan

David Maudlin — Thu, 10 Mar 2016 13:27:36 GMT

DGSketcher wrote:
David: "5" is not listed in the GDL manual and therefore I assume a risky option. Normal top view would be PROJECT2 3,270,2 is there some trick in using "5" ?

Doors and windows are created at a 90˚ rotation to their placement, so the "3" projection_code shows the face, not the top, of the door.

David

Re: Project2 for custom door plan

David Maudlin — Thu, 10 Mar 2016 13:33:36 GMT

patmay81 wrote:
I had tried PROJECT2 5, 0, 2... but not 90, that was my problem. I was not thinking of it as actually rotating the 3d view to an alternate plane, just around its own plane. 5, 90, 2 works great. 3, 270, 2 also works, not sure of the advantage of one over the other.

The 3, 270, 2 settings show the side of the door, not the top view here, not sure why it works for you. See my reply to DGSketcher.

David