topic Re: WIDO_ORIG_DIST Sign flip in Libraries & objects

WIDO_ORIG_DIST Sign flip

James Murray — Wed, 24 May 2023 09:41:36 GMT

Can anyone think of a reason that WIDO_ORIG_DIST would return a positive value in the model and the settings dialog, and a negative value in the report window, at the same time?

Or, is there another way to let a curved window know whether the reveal side is inside or outside the curve?

Re: WIDO_ORIG_DIST Sign flip

Laszlo Nagy — Thu, 16 Jul 2015 11:24:46 GMT

Does this help?:

http://ja.archicadwiki.com/Global%20GDL%20Parameters#WIDO_ORIG_DIST

The description of the variable may give the explanation to this riddle, especially this part:

The variable returns values with opposite signs in the Floor Plan and the 3D Window. If you look at Chapter 12.1 in the GDL manual you will see that the way a Window/Door is generated in 3D is that it is rotated 90 degrees around its own X-axis. This way a direction that was positive Y on the Floor Plan Window becomes negative Z in the 3D Window and a direction that was negative Y on the Floor Plan Window becomes positive Z in the 3D Window. So if the variable returned 1.6 meters in the Floor Plan Window it will return –1.6 meters in the 3D Window.

Re: WIDO_ORIG_DIST Sign flip

James Murray — Fri, 17 Jul 2015 18:10:34 GMT

Thanks Laszlo, it makes sense from a strict geometry perspective. But it's crazy-making for a user. It is consistent, once I reversed my interior/exterior logic in the 2D script. I don't know how I missed that page while searching, but I very grateful for you pointing it out.

Re: WIDO_ORIG_DIST Sign flip

Laszlo Nagy — Fri, 17 Jul 2015 19:25:44 GMT

You are welcome.