topic Re: Why is dwg export f***ed up in AC12? in Collaboration with other software

Why is dwg export f***ed up in AC12?

Anonymous — Sat, 20 Sep 2008 10:25:05 GMT

Dear Graphisoft, why do you have to f**** up dwg export with every new release?

It was a perfectly working feature in AC9 and 10, so why don't you leave it alone and spend your efforts on something usable, like copy in sections?!?

With every new release I expect there will be something wrong with dwg export and I shall not be able to communicate with engineers! And I am always right!

In AC12 there is no option to explode complex elements! The result is I ged every line, fill or window exported as a block into layer "1"! It even happens when I export sections!

Please, give us back the old translator, because we are trying to do our work with this program!

Re: Why is dwg export f***ed up in AC12?

Anonymous — Sat, 20 Sep 2008 10:25:47 GMT

The result in Autocad:

Re: Why is dwg export f***ed up in AC12?

Thomas Holm — Sat, 20 Sep 2008 11:05:22 GMT

Kliment,
(---)
Edited:
I should have checked before replying. My bad. I've got those (missing for you) Save options in my AC12 translators too, like the colleagues below.
Did you by any chance transfer your old AC11 translator to AC12, instead of re-creating your custom translator from scratch in AC12? I would not recommend that procedure, since if GS changes part of the working code, the old translator settings file might point in the wrong direction and miss some of the options.

Re: Why is dwg export f***ed up in AC12?

Erika Epstein — Sat, 20 Sep 2008 23:23:00 GMT

Interesting. Those options are available in the US version of AC12.

Re: Why is dwg export f***ed up in AC12?

Karl Ottenstein — Sat, 20 Sep 2008 23:47:45 GMT

Those options show up in my INT version as well as US....but appears that both versions refer to the same xml files, even if the program code is different.

Can somebody who does NOT have the US version confirm if they see the missing controls in Kliment's screenshot?

Kliment, can you verify that those controls are missing if you select any of the other (delivered) translators, as opposed to your custom one? Perhaps your custom xml is corrupted... You should also be able to open the xml file from 11 in 12 I think...Worth checking...

Thanks,
Karl

Re: Why is dwg export f***ed up in AC12?

Link — Sun, 21 Sep 2008 00:11:37 GMT

Karl wrote:
Can somebody who does NOT have the US version confirm if they see the missing controls in Kliment's screenshot?

I see them all here on the INT version.

Cheers,
Link.

Re: Why is dwg export f***ed up in AC12?

Anonymous — Mon, 22 Sep 2008 08:49:43 GMT

I got it!
Everything is fine if you save as dwg from plan. The fun starts when you try to save it in Secton - then these settings are missing!
Thank you GS for wasting a whole day of my time! Today is a national holiday in Bulgaria - The day of indipendance! And I am at the office!

Re: Why is dwg export f***ed up in AC12?

Erika Epstein — Mon, 22 Sep 2008 16:44:16 GMT

Kliment,
Why don't you do a re-install?

Re: Why is dwg export f***ed up in AC12?

Thomas Holm — Mon, 22 Sep 2008 18:58:07 GMT

kliment wrote:
Everything is fine if you save as dwg from plan. The fun starts when you try to save it in Secton - then these settings are missing!

But Kliment, this difference from plan behavior - no explode when Saving DWG from Section - was the same in AC11. So this doesn't mean that DWG export in AC12 is more f*d up in 12 than in 11.

But you may have found something still. If you didn't get block export from sections in AC11, but do now in 12, that means that GS has changed the way sections behave, but the DWG export translator hasn't kept up with this development. I can't recall that happening to me (but I don't have Autocad) - I seem to recall only getting lines and arcs from section export previously.

I hope that this is a pointer to real 3D item copy and paste in sections in the future. And that the DWG exporter will keep pace.