topic Re: 1920x1080 OR 1920x1200? in Installation & update

1920x1080 OR 1920x1200?

Anonymous — Sun, 13 Jun 2010 23:37:01 GMT

Hi,

I'm looking for a monitor to use as a dual setup along with my 17" Macbook Pro. I have stumbled upon a debate wether to go with the 1920x1080 monitor or 1920x1200 monitor. The 1920x1080 is a lot cheaper than the other one but I hear from a few people that this resolution isn't as practical because it does not have a high enough vertical value (i.e too letterbox like)

I wanted to see what other CAD users thought of this view because the reasons I'm getting a external monitor is soley for the use of ArchiCAD. Being as I'm a student I obviously want the cheapest option (by cheap I mean lower price, not poor quality) and so I have found a few very,very good Samsung monitor for £170 for a 24" 1920x1080. The lowest price I have seen a 1920x1200 monitor is £270, again with a Samsung.

I value any input regarding this, as I'm sure a lot of people on here also have a similar setup as me or have too faced this scenario.

Thank You

Re: 1920x1080 OR 1920x1200?

Gerald Hoffman — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 01:21:14 GMT

My own view is I would if at all possible get the higher resolution. I have a Laptop (not Mac) which has native resolution of 1920 X 1200 and I run an external 24" monitor with the same resolution in the office. I think the extra height is very helpful because of the toolbars and object info along the top. It would significantly reduce your drawing screen with the 1080 vertical height.

Cheers,

Re: 1920x1080 OR 1920x1200?

Anonymous — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 09:29:55 GMT

Gerald wrote:
My own view is I would if at all possible get the higher resolution. I have a Laptop (not Mac) which has native resolution of 1920 X 1200 and I run an external 24" monitor with the same resolution in the office. I think the extra height is very helpful because of the toolbars and object info along the top. It would significantly reduce your drawing screen with the 1080 vertical height.

Cheers,

Just out of curiosity, which external display do you have please?

I think it's worth saving for the 1920x1200 because as you said, the larger the screen (height) the better and I agree with you as my Mac has a resolution of 1920x1200.

Thank You

Re: 1920x1080 OR 1920x1200?

Gerald Hoffman — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 13:19:39 GMT

As indicated in my signature I use a Dell 24" Panel. It has been a very good monitor and the price is now about 40% of what I paid for it. This is a new model than mine and the specs look even better than mine.

Re: 1920x1080 OR 1920x1200?

Anonymous — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 13:28:17 GMT

I see loads of people using Dell monitors and I hear very good reviews about them. Unfortunatley it's out of my budget which is below £300, but thank you anyway.

I shall keep looking...

Re: 1920x1080 OR 1920x1200?

Erika Epstein — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 14:06:44 GMT

With this economy, have you checked for used monitors? Also manufacturer refurbished when available can knock 30-40% off the price and come with the guarantee.

Re: 1920x1080 OR 1920x1200?

Anonymous — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 14:10:22 GMT

Erika wrote:
With this economy, have you checked for used monitors? Also manufacturer refurbished when available can knock 30-40% off the price and come with the guarantee.

I tend not to buy 'Second hand goods' because myself and other family member have had bad experience with them. However, I'm checking the Apple store and other reliable stores for refurbished models.

I can find a 1920x1200 monitor but the brand isn't particulary good, it's called Iiyama.

Re: 1920x1080 OR 1920x1200?

Erika Epstein — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 14:22:07 GMT

I and many I know have bought refurbished Apple computers and monitors and been very happy, especially with the price. They come with the same warranty as the new items.

I did the same with a second Dell monitor some years ago am similarly very pleased with it; I am using it as I write this.

In the US when you are a student or teacher the schools usually offer severely discounted prices for computers and software. Do they do that in England?

Re: 1920x1080 OR 1920x1200?

Anonymous — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 14:25:39 GMT

What I meant to say is that when we bought a used item on eBay, after a few weeks it broke... I'm sure if you go directly to the manufacturer you will have a warranty. ( and I too have heard excellent things about Apple refurb's)

As far as I know, we or at least at my University doesn't sell used items, I know that in the US this is pretty 'big' and a very good idea. Again, AFAIK schools/Universities don't offer discounted software etc. only student licenses which we can require ourselves.

Re: 1920x1080 OR 1920x1200?

Erika Epstein — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 14:33:37 GMT

The discounts the Universities here offer is on new items, not used (all though they may also do that).

Re: 1920x1080 OR 1920x1200?

Anonymous — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 14:34:57 GMT

Erika wrote:
The discounts the Universities here offer is on new items, not used (all though they may also do that).

Nope, we don't get any of that unfortunatley. Apple is the only company I can get student discount from in electronics and software.

Re: 1920x1080 OR 1920x1200?

Anonymous — Mon, 14 Jun 2010 15:48:29 GMT

Here's one I've found, a Samsung Monitor:
http://www.samsung.com/uk/consumer/pc-peripherals/monitors/design/LS24TWHSUV/EN/index.idx?pagetype=prd_detail&tab=specification
But it only has a contract ratio of 2000:1 whereas most other have 5000:1 (although the native is 10000:1?)