topic can archicad detect any clash [was: crash] by itself? in Modeling

can archicad detect any clash [was: crash] by itself?

Anonymous — Thu, 19 Mar 2009 01:09:13 GMT

i know that from my friend Revit can detect crash [moderator: "clash"] by itself, although he think revit is not very clever.

however, can archicad do so?
for example, 2 parallel wall overlap a bit together

Re: can archicad detect any crash by itself?

David Maudlin — Thu, 19 Mar 2009 12:06:21 GMT

angus:

I think you are referring to clash detection. The MEP add-on objects (ducts, pipes) can detect clashes with building elements (walls, columns, etc) but not with each other. I believe that is the extent of clash detection within ArchiCAD presently.

David

Re: can archicad detect any crash by itself?

Barry Kelly — Fri, 20 Mar 2009 02:04:28 GMT

David wrote:
angus:

I think you are referring to clash detection.

Yes, Archicad is very good at CRASH detection.
The bug reporter comes up every time just so you know for sure.

David wrote:
angus:

The MEP add-on objects (ducts, pipes) can detect clashes with building elements (walls, columns, etc) but not with each other. I believe that is the extent of clash detection within ArchiCAD presently.

MEP is the only clash detection there is at the moment which is only good when MEP objects are used.

But you would think clash detection would be fairly easy to implement seeing as walls, beams columns, etc. can all automatically cut each other when they touch.

Barry.