topic Re: finding roof error ? in Modeling

finding roof error ?

Anonymous — Tue, 23 May 2023 12:46:36 GMT

i created a lot of roofs on the tops of my houses last week.
but this morning i get a error message that there is a problem with one the roofs.
the model still opens but it is just very annoying.
how can i find where the error is ???
i have about 120 roofs in my model ?

thanks.
Ian

Re: finding roof error ?

Anonymous — Tue, 01 Nov 2011 11:18:03 GMT

One way I have found to fix / find the corrupted elements is:
- start a second session of Archicad
- open 3D window in file with corruption
- select roof tool and select all (or use find and select) and cut
- switch to other session and paste cut elements (bad element won't be pasted)
- save and close corrupted file and then re-open
- go back to file where roofs pasted and select all and cut
- paste back into 3d window in original file

Re: finding roof error ?

Anonymous — Thu, 03 Nov 2011 07:27:33 GMT

maybe this helps.

the error report.

Anzahl der Prozessor-Kerne: 8
Ungültiges Polygon, Selbstüberschneidung oder Öffnung schneidet Polygonkanten (Dach-006)
Ungültiges Polygon, Selbstüberschneidung oder Öffnung schneidet Polygonkanten (Dach-006)
Ungültiges Polygon, Selbstüberschneidung oder Öffnung schneidet Polygonkanten (Dach-006)
Ungültiges Polygon, Selbstüberschneidung oder Öffnung schneidet Polygonkanten (Dach-006)
Ungültiges Polygon, Selbstüberschneidung oder Öffnung schneidet Polygonkanten (Dach-006)
Ungültiges Polygon, Selbstüberschneidung oder Öffnung schneidet Polygonkanten (Dach-006)
Ungültiges Polygon, Selbstüberschneidung oder Öffnung schneidet Polygonkanten (Dach-006)
Ungültiges Polygon, Selbstüberschneidung oder Öffnung schneidet Polygonkanten (Dach-006)
Ungültiges Polygon, Selbstüberschneidung oder Öffnung schneidet Polygonkanten (Dach-006)
Ungültiges Polygon, Selbstüberschneidung oder Öffnung schneidet Polygonkanten (Dach-006)
Ungültiges Polygon, Selbstüberschneidung oder Öffnung schneidet Polygonkanten (Dach-006)
Ungültiges Polygon, Selbstüberschneidung oder Öffnung schneidet Polygonkanten (Dach-006)
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Dokumentname : grundkarte
Berechnet : 0 Wände 194 Objekte 0 Stützen 53 Unterzüge
1154 Decken 0 Freiflächen 973 Dächer
Start-Zeit : 03.11.2011 08:15:33
Ende : 03.11.2011 08:26:14
Rechenzeit : 10 Minuten 41 Sekunden
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Projektion : Perspektive
Standpunkt : -1474.94 -875.474 958.283
Richtung : 0.702114 0.427967 -0.569105
Abstand : 745.588 Winkel : 60
Start-Zeit : 03.11.2011 08:26:14
Ende : 03.11.2011 08:26:14
Rechenzeit : 0 Sekunden
----------------------------------------------------------------------

Re: finding roof error ?

Stephen Dolbee — Thu, 03 Nov 2011 12:32:16 GMT

The error message should give the roof's ID#. If all of your roofs have different ID's, you should be able to identify it. Of course, it is tedious to select each roof to find the one with that ID. Scott's method might be best (I didn't know a corrupted roof wouldn't paste).

Re: finding roof error ?

Barry Kelly — Fri, 04 Nov 2011 01:32:52 GMT

Stephen wrote:
Of course, it is tedious to select each roof to find the one with that ID.

Use the "Find & Select" tool with the ID as one of your criteria.

Another method is to select or marque half of your job and view that in 3D.
If no error message then you know the problem is in the other half.
If there is an error you know which half to investigate further.

Nor select or marquee half of the half with the problem and keep repeating to narrow down your search area.
This method has been mntioned a few times in this forum - I think it may have been called a boolean search.

Barry.

Re: finding roof error ?

Anonymous — Fri, 04 Nov 2011 03:47:17 GMT

Barry wrote:
I think it may have been called a boolean search.

Barry.

Binary search, I think.

Re: finding roof error ?

Barry Kelly — Fri, 04 Nov 2011 03:54:37 GMT

s2art wrote:
Barry wrote:
I think it may have been called a boolean search.

Barry.
Binary search, I think.

That sounds better.
It's been a long week.
I was too lazy to try looking for it myself.

Thanks S2art.

Barry.