topic Re: Does Archicad drive your design? in Modeling

Does Archicad drive your design?

Anonymous — Sun, 09 Nov 2008 21:49:35 GMT

I know this is often discussed in other threads but I found myself the other day taking the easy way out on certain objects and building parts " 'cause its too hard or there's a few extra steps....". You know...the path of least resistance ! I confess I did

I wondered how may designs are influenced by that...maybe there's a reason mine look like Bauhaus rejects

Re: Does Archicad drive your design?

Dwight — Sun, 09 Nov 2008 22:24:08 GMT

Okay. I can accept that you are lazy.
Or, maybe it is that you aren't compensated to make better things?
Or, perhaps we share what used to grind me down: putting over-ambitious energy into preliminary things that SHOULD be coarse and feeling let down in the end because they change their mind about it. SO you cynically never do anything that isn't coarse.

What is true for BIM is true for design in general, the more unique a thing is, the longer it takes to detail and the more expensive it will ultimately be.

If your things look coarse or ill-composed, is that really Archicad's fault?

I feel that I spend more time being an architect with Archicad - actually having pleasure determining detailed forms and learning to be quick with swanky modeling.

Re: Does Archicad drive your design?

Anonymous — Mon, 10 Nov 2008 06:45:51 GMT

What different tools were used to model that image?

Re: Does Archicad drive your design?

Dwight — Mon, 10 Nov 2008 06:51:37 GMT

That is all done with the Complex Profile - in Archicad 12 where the curved wall can be the extrusion controller.

And all words come from the Greek.

Re: Does Archicad drive your design?

Anonymous — Wed, 12 Nov 2008 00:31:23 GMT

Dwight wrote:
Okay. I can accept that you are lazy.
Or, maybe it is that you aren't compensated to make better things?
Or, perhaps we share what used to grind me down: putting over-ambitious energy into preliminary things that SHOULD be coarse and feeling let down in the end because they change their mind about it. SO you cynically never do anything that isn't coarse.

What is true for BIM is true for design in general, the more unique a thing is, the longer it takes to detail and the more expensive it will ultimately be.

If your things look coarse or ill-composed, is that really Archicad's fault?

I feel that I spend more time being an architect with Archicad - actually having pleasure determining detailed forms and learning to be quick with swanky modeling.

I've been an architect for 30 years DWIGHT...don't call me lazy.
I'm very impressed you can do a a curved something and I'm pleased you never take a lazy shortcut.

This what I was talking about as my lazy work:
Also go to http://www.forarchitects.com/firm.aspx?id=1595 and have a look at the hotel/apartment project Sydney 3D study done in Archicad

Re: Does Archicad drive your design?

Dwight — Wed, 12 Nov 2008 02:26:36 GMT

Me, I'm lazy all the time.

Don't be insulted. I did give you three options.....

My point is that when a guy observes that he is taking the "easy way out" what is it supposed to mean?

Re: Does Archicad drive your design?

Erika Epstein — Wed, 12 Nov 2008 17:26:00 GMT

"Does Archicad drive your design?"

It shouldn't. CAD limitation designs are one of the reasons many design schools have gone back to teaching students how to sketch on paper.