topic Re: Stairmaker & Fill Categories in Modeling

Stairmaker & Fill Categories

owen — Thu, 25 May 2023 15:33:35 GMT

I'm having one of those 'I could swear i'd used this before' moments ...

Stairmaker only shows Drafting-category fills in the dialogs for the sectional properties of the stair structure!?!?

Am i missing something or is that how its meant to be?

In what world GS does it make sense that my CUT FILLS are not available in a dialog to define what fills are seen when i CUT THE STAIR?

sorry bad day but illogical crap like this always seems to come up at these times

.
.
.

or does everyone just make all their fills available in all categories to avoid situations like this? i'd just like to keep the fill list relevant (and 'help' people to use the correct fills)

Re: Stairmaker & Fill Categories

Laszlo Nagy — Wed, 07 Dec 2011 13:13:29 GMT

This must be a bug.
I will report it to GS.

Re: Stairmaker & Fill Categories

owen — Wed, 07 Dec 2011 13:36:26 GMT

Lazlo,

Now i'm sure I'm going crazy - if this is a bug its not new. I've just checked in AC14 and same problem .. fills in stair maker are limited to Drafting category.

.. and its not just stairs. Frame settings in doors and windows also only allow Drafting fills (in 14 & 15)

i guess they won't regard this as a bug ... but i'd certainly call it sloppy QA or application of one's own logic (just read the Help on Fill Categories and tell me this usage of Drafting fills makes sense)

os

Re: Stairmaker & Fill Categories

Laszlo Nagy — Wed, 07 Dec 2011 13:53:22 GMT

So it looks like it is a more general problem.
I have sent the report so I am sure they will investigate it.

If you see it anyplace else please post it because that also helps their work.

Re: Stairmaker & Fill Categories

owen — Thu, 08 Dec 2011 01:48:27 GMT

OK this seems to be a bug in the fills being made available to GDL elements in their settings dialogs - it affects all objects I have tested, including custom objects so I know its not a scripting issue. Also the problem doesn't occur in the GDL Editor environment as you can actually use an fill when setting a parameters default value.

To test:

1. I drew a Cut fill on plan and saved as an object and placed. The GDL 'hard-coded' Cut Fill shows.
2. I edited the auto-script to make the fill type parametric. The Cut Fill is available in the fill selection dialog in the GDL Editor so set this to be the default parameter value.
3. The object displays the Cut Fill used as the default fill parameter in the Object Settings dialog
4. Now if I try to change the parameter value, the Cut Fills are not available in the fill selection dialog.

Apologies for the image rotation .. forum has a stupid 1600 wide x 1200 high limitation ... so my 1400 high x 1000 wide image wasn't accepted. Again, please fix the ridiculous file size limitations .. its 2011. I'm sure GS can afford a few more TB's to store the forum data. I know you can link to external sites but these links go dead in time, devaluing the refering posts

cheers,

os

Re: Stairmaker & Fill Categories

Anonymous — Thu, 08 Dec 2011 02:27:29 GMT

owen wrote:
.. forum has a stupid 1600 wide x 1200 high limitation ...

cheers,

os

I'd like to second that!

Re: Stairmaker & Fill Categories

Judit Boros — Mon, 19 Dec 2011 13:08:45 GMT

Dear Owen and Users,

Thank you for this Talk-report. We investigated this issue and we plan to correct it as soon as possible.
Please note that in the next upcoming Hotfix ( due February) this can not be included yet.

Regards,