topic incorrect PBC behaviour in Modeling

incorrect PBC behaviour

leceta — Wed, 24 May 2023 10:42:39 GMT

Hi all!

Need your help!

I am having an issue with PBC. Please, see attached image

I´am creating a composite.

Initially, the intersection between two walls with the newly created composite behaves as expected. But when i add a new external finish to the composites, an annoying and incorrect line apperas in the intersection.

Building material priorities are checked, and they are ok.

Neither nothing strange with layer intersection ID (by the way, both walls are in the same layer)

May be a bug?

thanks!!
aitor

Re: incorrect PBC behaviour

Anonymous — Tue, 05 Jan 2016 19:38:09 GMT

Change the finish material Type to a finish material.

leceta wrote:
Hi all!

Need your help!

I am having an issue with PBC. Please, see attached image

I´am creating a composite.

Initially, the intersection between two walls with the newly created composite behaves as expected. But when i add a new external finish to the composites, an annoying and incorrect line apperas in the intersection.

Building material priorities are checked, and they are ok.

Neither nothing strange with layer intersection ID (by the way, both walls are in the same layer)

May be a bug?

thanks!!
aitor

Re: incorrect PBC behaviour

Barry Kelly — Wed, 06 Jan 2016 02:35:06 GMT

vgodzb wrote:
Change the finish material Type to a finish material.

If this doesn't work (can't test at the moment) then try playing around with the strength of the external skin building material.
You may even need to create an internal skin and an external skin BM rather than just one.

There was a post a little while back (I am sure it was in this forum but I can't find it) about a bug when the BM strength was below a certain figure (around 450 I think). This caused problems with the automatic trimming.

I wish I could find the post - I know I replied to it.
I am sure it was very recent and have checked all my posts in the last 2 months but can't see it.
If I get time later I might experiment.

Barry.

Re: incorrect PBC behaviour

Fra — Wed, 06 Jan 2016 10:46:27 GMT

There was a post a little while back (I am sure it was in this forum but I can't find it) about a bug when the BM strength was below a certain figure (around 450 I think). This caused problems with the automatic trimming.

I wish I could find the post - I know I replied to it.
I am sure it was very recent and have checked all my posts in the last 2 months but can't see it.
If I get time later I might experiment.

It could be this the post ? :
http://archicad-talk.graphisoft.com/viewtopic.php?t=51191&start=0

Francesco

Re: incorrect PBC behaviour

leceta — Wed, 06 Jan 2016 20:17:02 GMT

There was a post a little while back (I am sure it was in this forum but I can't find it) about a bug when the BM strength was below a certain figure (around 450 I think). This caused problems with the automatic trimming.

exactly this is the problem. I was using Building Material with a priority higer than 545. This is exactly when the problem starts. With 546 it doesnt work.

Thank guys!

Re: incorrect PBC behaviour

Barry Kelly — Thu, 07 Jan 2016 02:48:56 GMT

Fra wrote:
It could be this the post ? :
http://archicad-talk.graphisoft.com/viewtopic.php?t=51191&start=0

Yes that is the one.
Thanks Francesco.

Barry.

Re: incorrect PBC behaviour

Katalin Borszeki — Thu, 25 Feb 2016 13:42:45 GMT

Hi All, we have contacted the user and got the answer that the problem could not be introduced any more. Thanks, k