topic Re: AC 24 Bug Please confirm in Modeling

AC 24 Slab Bug? [Answer: changed behavior in AC 22 and above]

Brett Brown — Thu, 25 May 2023 15:33:10 GMT

Using the Slab tool, butt 2 together edge to edge with one's corner shorter. Now select the larger one and try and put a node at the intersection point. It won't let you, you have to put the node away from the intersection and drag it to it. (The 2 identical slabs don't merge like in 23)
This works fine in 20.
Tried in 23 and it is slightly different only in the fact that the two slabs merge ( new setting somewhere?) and you still can't put a node at the intersection point.
I seem to remember a new feature about slabs merging but you still should be able to put a node at the intersecting point.

Re: AC 24 Bug Please confirm

Barry Kelly — Wed, 21 Oct 2020 01:52:48 GMT

No problem for me adding a node on either slab at the intersection.

Full version 24 (AUS) on Windows system - so different to your set up.

And yes there is a new Model View Option setting to adjust the joining line of slabs from version 23 onwards.

Barry.

Re: AC 24 Bug Please confirm

Brett Brown — Wed, 21 Oct 2020 02:21:43 GMT

Tried Solo on Windows, same problem, instead of the pet palette to add a node etc I get the dimension 1,2, palette as though I was starting another slab.

Re: AC 24 Bug Please confirm

Minh Nguyen — Tue, 27 Oct 2020 10:48:15 GMT

Dear Brett,

Thank you for the report and I am very sorry for the issue!

Unfortunately, I was unable to replicate this issue. Could you make a small video about what happened when you cannot add a node at the intersection of the slabs?

Thank you very much for your help! I look forward to hearing from you soon!

Best regards,
Minh

Re: AC 24 Bug Please confirm

Minh Nguyen — Fri, 30 Oct 2020 08:37:01 GMT

Dear all,

Thanks to Brett's video and explanation, we were able to identify what was the problem here:

- On AC21 and previous versions: when we have 2 slabs next to each other, if we select one slab > click Slab tool > we can add a node at intersection by clicking at the point

- From AC22: this action will start adding a hole on the slab instead. To add the point, we need to click the Arrow tool > click on the edge of the selected slab > Insert new node > move the node to the intersection point.

This happens due to a code cleaning up in AC22. When a slab is selected and the Slab tool is activated, the next action is always be adding a new hole regardless of where you click on the slab (from nodes, from edges or inside the slab).

I hope my explanation is clear enough. Please let me know if you have any further question!
Thank you very much!

Best regards,
Minh

Re: AC 24 Bug Please confirm

Brett Brown — Fri, 30 Oct 2020 09:00:55 GMT

Thanks for the explanation Minh, cheers

Re: AC 24 Bug Please confirm

Barry Kelly — Fri, 30 Oct 2020 09:05:54 GMT

mnguyen wrote:
To add the point, we need to click the Arrow tool > click on the edge of the selected slab > Insert new node > move the node to the intersection point.

Ah, that is why it worked for me.
I always have a habit of returning to the selection tool when I need to select something.

Barry.

Re: AC 24 Bug Please confirm

Laszlo Nagy — Fri, 30 Oct 2020 17:38:46 GMT

mnguyen wrote:
- From AC22: this action will start adding a hole on the slab instead. To add the point, we need to click the Arrow tool > click on the edge of the selected slab > Insert new node > move the node to the intersection point.

This method works regardless of which Tool is active so you don't have to switch to the Arrow Tool for it to work.
Also, I suspect this change is not relevant to Slab so much as it is relevant to all polygon-type elements. So it would also apply in the case of Roofs, Meshes, Fills, etc.