topic Morph convertion "BUG" in Modeling

Morph convertion "BUG"

Botonis — Thu, 19 Oct 2023 13:24:30 GMT

When you have an opening that goes through more than one elements , when you convert to morph it's taken in condideration only for the initial element on which it was created.

Re: Morph convertion "BUG"

Mahmoud Qenawi — Thu, 19 Oct 2023 15:16:43 GMT

Hi @Botonis,

I think it’s not a bug & rather it’s a good catch.

AFAIU objects like windows & doors are associated only to the element they are belong to.

So I think the opening is only attached to only one element and as an extra function it can penetrate other elements that lets you create a shaft penetrating many slabs or a cable tray passing through many walls.

Re: Morph convertion "BUG"

Patrick M — Thu, 19 Oct 2023 21:39:23 GMT

what happens if you convert both elements to morph at the same time?

Re: Morph convertion "BUG"

Barry Kelly — Fri, 20 Oct 2023 00:59:26 GMT

@Patrick M wrote:

what happens if you convert both elements to morph at the same time?

That is the way to do it.

The actual opening can not be converted to a morph.

Only the containing (parent) element can be converted to a morph.

If you convert just the parent element, then there will no longer be an opening (can't have openings in morphs) and therefore no opening in the attached elements any more.

So you have to convert those attached elements too at the same time as you convert the parent element.

You can't convert the attached elements first, as the opening does not belong to them and will not be converted.

Barry.

Re: Morph convertion "BUG"

Botonis — Fri, 20 Oct 2023 08:09:15 GMT

Strange. One case of a slab with a connected opening that when it is converted to morph it does not consider the opening. Is this the way it should be?

I feel something is not stable here but is migh be just an idea.....

Re: Morph convertion "BUG"

Barry Kelly — Fri, 20 Oct 2023 08:25:08 GMT

You have to convert the parent slab that contains the opening and the other slabs connected to the opening at the same time.

Converting just the connected slabs will not include the opening.

Barry.

Re: Morph convertion "BUG"

Botonis — Fri, 20 Oct 2023 08:58:09 GMT

Barry. I am not sure whether this is the solution for all cases..

The second video shows an opening which is attached to the slab already. When you convert to morph the slab takes its initial shape.

Is this the way it should be? I am not sure.

In the first video it was converted correctly.

Re: Morph convertion "BUG"

Barry Kelly — Fri, 20 Oct 2023 09:24:38 GMT

Sorry I didn't notice the videos.

I wondered if it had to do with the direction the opening cut through the slab.

I tried one along the length of the slab and at a slight angle and that still worked as expected.

No matter where I place the opening it seems to convert to a morph OK.

Barry.

Re: Morph convertion "BUG"

Botonis — Fri, 20 Oct 2023 09:42:41 GMT

Ok. This is one of those times that this behaviour is file "specific".

When I copy the slab with the opening to a new file it works as expected.

In this certain file it won't. So something is affecting the converting action!!!!!!!!!!!!

A file repair didn;t change a thing.

Are all those things happening just to me!!!!????

Re: Morph convertion "BUG"

Botonis — Fri, 20 Oct 2023 09:46:08 GMT

And suddenly after opening a new file and perform the action corrreclty

the previous file is working fine!!!!!

I guess it had to see how the action is correctly performed to act similarly.

One of the thing that science cannot explain..................