topic Re: Layer Settings "0" -> prefabricated elements in Modeling

Layer Settings "0" -> prefabricated elements

Lukas Oelmueller — Wed, 20 Mar 2024 01:03:18 GMT

For the increasing planning of buildings with prefabricated elements (wood/concrete), I would like to work with the "0" setting in the layer setup to avoid intersections. This works well in the floor plan. I get the desired separation lines. In 3D, I also don't get any intersections of the components, but the textures (materials) merge. As a result, I don't get separation lines in section and elevation views.

Does anyone know a solution? (Apart from customizing textures for each component)

Operating system used: Mac Intel-based all

Re: Layer Settings "0" -> prefabricated elements

Ahmed_K — Wed, 13 Mar 2024 11:44:43 GMT

Intersection priority prevent building materials from intersecting, for exemple, hidden operators are placed in a hidden layer with intersection priority set different from all layers, to prevent hiddent elements from generating automatic intersections with other elements.

In your exemple, i thinks there is no need to differentiate prefabricated element layer from others, you need to assign for them a strong building material, wich will cut other BMs,

Re: Layer Settings "0" -> prefabricated elements

Lukas Oelmueller — Wed, 13 Mar 2024 11:49:26 GMT

no. sorry. I think you misunderstood my problem. I know everything about intersections.

My post is rather about the inconsistency in Archicad.

Re: Layer Settings "0" -> prefabricated elements

Barry Kelly — Thu, 14 Mar 2024 01:48:54 GMT

Intersection group numbers in the layers only control the intersection of elements (as you have discovered).

Adjoining elements do not intersect, but if the surfases are in perfect alignment, then they will blend into one continuous surface with no joins.

There is no setting I know of to alter this, except for using duplicate surface materials in an alternating pattern.

Barry.

Re: Layer Settings "0" -> prefabricated elements

Lingwisyer — Thu, 14 Mar 2024 04:15:55 GMT

If it is just prefab panels, could you use the Cube object? It will not react to stretches and marquees if you need to make modification though...

Re: Layer Settings "0" -> prefabricated elements

Botonis — Thu, 14 Mar 2024 05:34:10 GMT

Just to simulate the idea of a pre fabricated element with custom dimensions I might have tried using a curtain wall if design allows it. This way it is easy to separate anything in all aspects and both in 2d and 3d.

Re: Layer Settings "0" -> prefabricated elements

furtonb — Thu, 14 Mar 2024 09:48:46 GMT

I second the original post: please make this behaviour consistent, I don't want to duplicate surfaces and leave tiny gaps between objects, or have multiple layers of editing (e.g. curtain walls). Setting the layer intersection group to 0 should also prevent the merging of surfaces, or this can be a feature flag somewhere that you can toggle based on your preference, to keep everyone happy.:)

Re: Layer Settings "0" -> prefabricated elements

hevi — Fri, 15 Mar 2024 10:00:58 GMT

Personally I find it weird that intersection is the default - I guess it makes some sense for a coarse approach to modelling but as we now modelled more discrete elements/components as parts of systems it would make much more sense to actively decide what should intersect. And of course - it should not be controlled through layers but rather through the in AC missing system/group concept.