topic Re: mep AC25 vs mep 28 the winner is AC25 in Modeling

mep AC25 vs mep 28 the winner is AC25

Ismael Gonzalez — Mon, 14 Oct 2024 20:10:40 GMT

"Try to do what you see in the video in Archicad 28, it's that simple, this is what I did in Archicad 25 without any problem.

Quickly place an Accessory in line turn it and move your key and take the line with controlled degrees all at once. Archicad must give its users the option to keep using Ac25's MEP while they fix all the errors of 26/27/28."

(Translation from Eduardo Rolon, below. Reminder: Only English posts are allowed in this Community.]

~~INTENTA HACER LO QUE VES EN EL VIDEO EN ARCHICAD 28, ASI DE SENCILLO, ESTO QUE HACIA ARCHICAD 25 SIN NINGUN PROBLEMA~~

COLOCAR RAPIDAMENTE UN ACCESORIO EN LINEA GIRARLO Y MOVER SU LLAVE Y LLEVAR LA LINEA CON GRADOS CONTROLADOS TODO A LA VEZ. ARCHICAD DEBE PLANTEAR A LOS CONSUMIDORES LA POSIBILIDAD DE ELEGIR QUEDARSE CON EL MEP DEL 25 MIENTRAS CORRIGEN TODO LOS ERRORES DEL 26/27/28

Operating system used: Windows 11

Re: mep AC25 vs mep 28 the winner is AC25

Eduardo Rolon — Mon, 14 Oct 2024 20:11:11 GMT

Por favor escribe en inglés.

This is an english language forum.

Translation:

"Try to do what you see in the video in Archicad 28, it's that simple, this is what I did in Archicad 25 without any problem.

Re: mep AC25 vs mep 28 the winner is AC25

Patrick M — Wed, 09 Oct 2024 21:47:28 GMT

yeah, seeing a LOT of deficiencies in the AC27/28 MEP tools

Re: mep AC25 vs mep 28 the winner is AC25

Bricklyne Clarence — Thu, 10 Oct 2024 21:02:49 GMT

Wait,....

.....the MEP tool is STILL broken?

Geez!!

How many versions do they need to get it right?

And to think that they're marketing it as one of the highlight "new" tools for version 28 (...........again).

So technically it's not even an "upgrade" as they're selling it.

It's a LITERAL downgrade from the MEP tools in versions 25-26 if those versions of the tool can outperform this latest iteration of it.

And this is the kind of thing that Graphisoft wants to force all users into a Subscription-only license model?

Good grief, Charlie Brown!!

Re: mep AC25 vs mep 28 the winner is AC25

Ismael Gonzalez — Fri, 11 Oct 2024 07:45:26 GMT

Well yes, you can't even place accessories in line or rotate them and most of the objects in libraries are not modified to work and connect and their rotating parameters and others do not work, the toilets do not connect and a long etc etc I have made entire factories of more than 40,000 m2 with AC25 with this new tool from AC28 it would not be possible.

Re: mep AC25 vs mep 28 the winner is AC25

JJMARQUEZ — Fri, 11 Oct 2024 17:42:02 GMT

Hola,
The MEP for AC5 and AC26 is the same. See if this helps you to continue working with AC27/28.

https://youtu.be/sSzi-MvIt0E?si=vqIJodeGxDb2FxUb&t=1798

Un saludo.

Re: mep AC25 vs mep 28 the winner is AC25

Ismael Gonzalez — Fri, 11 Oct 2024 20:28:23 GMT

The AC26 Mep was the worst of all, where the failures of mep graphisoft began, it is to introduce even more problems by mixing versions, and when you want to share with other users in team everything goes to **beep**, I don't think the user should try to correct the errors of graphisoft, right?

Re: mep AC25 vs mep 28 the winner is AC25

JJMARQUEZ — Mon, 14 Oct 2024 13:19:53 GMT

Hola,

I have no errors in MEP 26 when using Bimcloud. And I assure you that it is the same as MEP 25.
I have not responded to you to solve the problem for GS. I have written to you so that you have an alternative to continue working with AC27/28 without suffering the problems that their MEPs have.

Un saludo.