topic Re: Change a 3D setting of a 2D View? in Modeling

Change a 3D setting of a 2D View?

James Murray — Fri, 26 May 2023 13:06:25 GMT

Stumped:

I've got elevation views. When I defined them, I had 'Transparency in Shading' ON in the 3D window settings. This is a mistake, and I would like to modify the views with the fix. Trouble is, when you go to the settings of the views, the 3D settings are grayed out.

So we have a 2D view with a 3D setting stuck to it, with no access to the 3D settings. (Not that the setting shouldn't be saved, but we should talk about whether SEs should be governed by 3D window settings. Another time.)

I never missed that redefine button until now! I thought I could trick it by going to the view settings with the 3D window in front, but no luck. Any suggestions?

Re: Change a 3D setting of a 2D View?

ci-JoshOs — Tue, 01 Aug 2006 21:26:34 GMT

I have reported this to GS and they have acknowledged it as a bug.
Hopefully be fixed soon.
The only workaround is to change the 3D window setting and then make a new view(as opposed to modifying a current one).

Re: Change a 3D setting of a 2D View?

James Murray — Tue, 01 Aug 2006 22:35:23 GMT

henrypootel wrote:
make a new view

That's what I was afraid of...Thanks for the info.

Re: Change a 3D setting of a 2D View?

__archiben — Tue, 01 Aug 2006 22:43:09 GMT

James wrote:
Stumped:

I've got elevation views. When I defined them, I had 'Transparency in Shading' ON in the 3D window settings. This is a mistake, and I would like to modify the views with the fix. Trouble is, when you go to the settings of the views, the 3D settings are grayed out.

So we have a 2D view with a 3D setting stuck to it, with no access to the 3D settings. (Not that the setting shouldn't be saved, but we should talk about whether SEs should be governed by 3D window settings. Another time.)

I never missed that redefine button until now! I thought I could trick it by going to the view settings with the 3D window in front, but no luck. Any suggestions?

i stumbled on this too . . . but even though the 3D settings are greyed out, they do change if you use the 'get current window's settings' button . . .

so - if you go to the 3D window settings whilst in sect/elev window, then click on your view, it can be 'redefined' . . . although in a more roundabout way than we were used to in 9.

HTH
~/archiben

Re: Change a 3D setting of a 2D View?

Link — Wed, 02 Aug 2006 00:01:14 GMT

~/archiben wrote:
James wrote:
Stumped:

I've got elevation views. When I defined them, I had 'Transparency in Shading' ON in the 3D window settings. This is a mistake, and I would like to modify the views with the fix. Trouble is, when you go to the settings of the views, the 3D settings are grayed out.

So we have a 2D view with a 3D setting stuck to it, with no access to the 3D settings. (Not that the setting shouldn't be saved, but we should talk about whether SEs should be governed by 3D window settings. Another time.)

I never missed that redefine button until now! I thought I could trick it by going to the view settings with the 3D window in front, but no luck. Any suggestions?
i stumbled on this too . . . but even though the 3D settings are greyed out, they do change if you use the 'get current window's settings' button . . .

so - if you go to the 3D window settings whilst in sect/elev window, then click on your view, it can be 'redefined' . . . although in a more roundabout way than we were used to in 9.

HTH
~/archiben

And you've tried this have you mate?

I'll have to take notes - I've not never had any success with it and have just recreated the views. The uncertain integration of 2D & 3D settings needs a lot more ironing out. The same thing occurs in reverse to a lesser extent - 3D views don't actually use Model View Options but they are assigned anyway. Some legacy options prove difficult to get rid of.

Cheers,
Link.

Re: Change a 3D setting of a 2D View?

James Murray — Wed, 02 Aug 2006 00:38:37 GMT

~/archiben wrote:
if you go to the 3D window settings whilst in sect/elev window, then click on your view, it can be 'redefined' . . . although in a more roundabout way

I was so pleased to see this answer...but I can't make it go. I've tried these steps:

Activate SE view
3D Win Settings - Trans Off
Rebuild SE: Trans appears off
Highlight view - View Settings - Get Current - OK (SE is frontmost)
SE window rebuilds by itself: Trans is back on.

OR

Activate SE view
3D Win Settings - Trans Off
3D Window (OpenGL)
Highlight view - View Settings - Get Current - OK (3D is frontmost)
Close 3D win
Rebuild SE: Trans appears off
Activate SE view: Trans on
(Note: The view's zoom was changed, apparently by the 3D)

OR

Activate SE view
3D Win Settings - Trans Off
3D Window (OpenGL)
Back to SE - SE window rebuilds by itself: Trans appears off
Highlight view - View Settings - Get Current - OK (SE is frontmost)
Activate SE view: Trans on

OR

Activate SE view
3D Window (OpenGL)
3D Win Settings - Trans Off - 3D rebuilds
Back to SE - rebuilds by itself: Trans appears off
Highlight view - View Settings - Get Current - OK (SE is frontmost)
Activate SE view: Trans on

OR

3D Window (OpenGL)
3D Win Settings - Trans Off - 3D rebuilds
Open SE Win (not view): Trans appears off
Highlight view - View Settings - Get Current - OK (SE is frontmost)
Activate SE view: Trans on

They need to offer direct control of the 3D settings as they do the 2D.

Re: Change a 3D setting of a 2D View?

James Murray — Wed, 02 Aug 2006 00:40:40 GMT

Link wrote:
Cheers,
Link.

Oh, hey Link. I didn't see you, I was, ah, busy...

Re: Change a 3D setting of a 2D View?

Link — Wed, 02 Aug 2006 01:28:08 GMT

James wrote:
Link wrote:
Cheers,
Link.
Oh, hey Link. I didn't see you, I was, ah, busy...

...trying to find that ever-elusive last 20% of functionality again!

Cheers,
Link.

Re: Change a 3D setting of a 2D View?

ci-JoshOs — Wed, 02 Aug 2006 03:29:28 GMT

The bug is that the method Ben describes should work, but it doesn't.
At the moment the only way to make it work, is to create a new view(which is really annoying if you use clone folders).

Re: Change a 3D setting of a 2D View?

__archiben — Wed, 02 Aug 2006 04:33:54 GMT

henrypootel wrote:
The bug is that the method Ben describes should work, but it doesn't.
At the moment the only way to make it work, is to create a new view(which is really annoying if you use clone folders).

i saw the greyed-out 'Redefine Image Settings with Current' checkbox spring to life and figured that the view was being updated. you'd think by now i'd have learnt to check that it did actually work as planned. doh!

~/archiben

Re: Change a 3D setting of a 2D View?

__archiben — Wed, 23 Aug 2006 22:16:20 GMT

fixed in 966. well noticed laura!

http://archicad-talk.graphisoft.com/viewtopic.php?t=11911&highlight=

~/archiben