topic Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey in Modeling

!Restored: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

Rob — Thu, 25 May 2023 16:15:26 GMT

I am just curious how many of you are using the actual Graphisoft corner window tool. We are completely ignoring it and using Door-Window builder instead.
Please vote in the poll to improve current status of opening creation.

thanks

Administrator guys would it possible to make this poll sticky for a while? Thanks...

Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

LiHigh — Sun, 11 Mar 2007 06:06:56 GMT

corner window tool is useless..........

Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

Djordje — Sun, 11 Mar 2007 14:07:08 GMT

Rob wrote:
Administrator guys would it possible to make this poll sticky for a while? Thanks...

Welcome ...

Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

Anonymous — Sun, 11 Mar 2007 15:46:28 GMT

I have tried the GS tool and found it wanting. I use custom parts instead.

Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

PatriciaLe_o — Mon, 12 Mar 2007 11:00:39 GMT

I've never used corner window, but the openings issue always annoys me. I can't understand the separation between door and window and also the material division. If we take a door as something that goes until floor level and that we pass through it, I can have a wooden window that looks like a door and is made of aluminum!

Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

Anonymous — Tue, 13 Mar 2007 13:43:24 GMT

never use it. Also, how does one cast a vote?

Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

Anonymous — Tue, 13 Mar 2007 13:44:42 GMT

when I returned to the thread, I was able to vote. Didn't show up the when I opened it this morning.

Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

__archiben — Tue, 13 Mar 2007 21:05:07 GMT

i've tried it once or twice, but it's too flakey. i also had an issue several years ago whereby a corner window combined with IFC and teamwork resulted in duplications: 1 (2?) corner window very quickly becomes just over a million after 19 send and receives . . . i've been hesitant since!

Rip wrote:
when I returned to the thread, I was able to vote. Didn't show up the when I opened it this morning.

you have to be logged in . . .

~/archiben

Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

TomWaltz — Tue, 13 Mar 2007 23:48:40 GMT

Rob wrote:
I am just curious how many of you are using the actual Graphisoft corner window tool. We are completely ignoring it and using Door-Window builder instead.
Please vote in the poll to improve current status of opening creation.

There's a corner window tool? 😉

Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

Anonymous — Thu, 15 Mar 2007 18:19:04 GMT

Corner Windows is one of those things Graphisoft have to work to make it work. I post a few months ago an issue with that tool. I will love to make a glass corner window with frameless!

Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

Srinivas — Thu, 15 Mar 2007 18:56:37 GMT

YA.H.VE wrote:
I will love to make a glass corner window with frameless!

Did you try this? Please see the attached Image.

Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

Anonymous — Thu, 29 Mar 2007 22:08:37 GMT

I used't twice but I prefer to use archiglass .it is very nice

Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

Anonymous — Sat, 31 Mar 2007 23:04:18 GMT

Graphisoft must think themselves seriously about the way they offer windows and doors to us as - international - customers.

A lot of anger can be solved by adding extra parameters to the INT version. THIS HAS ALREADY BEEN DONE within the localized German Library. Why the difference ????

The German library offers :
- an option to set different sizes of the window frame at the left, right, top, ... : important to get a thin frame at the corner like I want
- the possibility for different reveal at each window and not mirror like as in the INT version

I'm sure other localized versions will have more / less / different / ... options and I don't agree with this policy as far as it concerns general and not area specific information.

TIP : for corner windows especially I think it would be worth gold to have all windows and doors available as single but still parametric "objects" also (like storefronts f.e.). With the help of empty windows I would position the objects just the way I want !

Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

Andy Thomson — Sun, 01 Apr 2007 13:41:04 GMT

I have witnessed a lot of user grief in this area. Will have to try the GER corner windows. The library localization has become a real problem, we need a better universal library that subsequently gets language and standard localized only if necessary. Currently, the Germans have parts that work (and lots more of them), where the rest of us do not.

Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

Anonymous — Thu, 19 Apr 2007 10:54:35 GMT

haven't used the corner window in v10 yet but in previous versions it was the most fickle thing... many teeth pulling moments!! doesn't sound like much has changed in this version yet...

can i just add my frustration insofar as the windows and doors go in v10 IN GENERAL! I'm finding all sorts of little bugs which most of the time i just work around as i haven't got the time to report all of them... i will do one of these days, but in the mean time.... aaaaaaaaarrrrrrrrrrrggggghhhhhhh!! is a noise that come out of my side of the office rather a lot!

Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

alexliz24 — Thu, 17 May 2007 15:11:13 GMT

Never used it. Ever.

Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

Jefferson — Thu, 17 May 2007 16:04:16 GMT

Joeri -

The more we learn about disparity between libraries the frustration grows about who has what, and how it works, or doesn't. Many of us have had discussions with other international users about this and the feelings seem unanimous. It needs to be addressed. Why a localized library? What's the point? One library please! Allow me to pick and choose what I need/want, I'm the one creating the model. Having the full compliment of objects/add-ons to choose from can't be any more complex than the rest of the program! And, check me if this logic doesn't make sense, but wouldn't it be simpler for Graphisoft to simply support a single library, with different languages?

I am wondering, and hoping, someone who better understands the nuts and bolts functionality of the program can comment, about sharing between users some of the more desirable library parts, or in this case an .apx. I assume the only safe way to implement this within one's one system, not intended by design to operate with these included, would be a strict and consistent effort to properly rename these objects/tools and save/load them from your own personal library/add-on environment. Personal responsibility, I can live with that. This may of course be overly-simplistic and just wishful thinking, then again it just might work, and.............if it did, we as users, could certainly just start sharing, via the very GDL Depository, right here

To that end, Joeri would you consider sending me your corner window .apx, I'll give it a try and report back. [I briefly attempted to navigate the Greman webpage on my own, but no German here so.............]

Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

Anonymous — Tue, 26 Jun 2007 12:20:10 GMT

It does seem ridiculous that there are different libraries for different countries when we in the UK get Archicad with log wall types. I mean how many times will I be using that particular construction? In fact I wonder how many times anyone in the USA uses log walls!?? Theres got to be more important things to add like proper planar glass roofs and walls, spider brackets and structure for glass walls, interesting balustrades in glass, mesh balconies and steel supports with timber decking (this would make a brilliant intelligent object to have in Archicad), a standard disabled toilet layout in 3d, interior and exterior lights that have the lamps already setup to reflect modern lighting available etc

Nats

Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

Anonymous — Tue, 26 Jun 2007 20:43:28 GMT

YA.H.VE wrote:
Corner Windows is one of those things Graphisoft have to work to make it work. I post a few months ago an issue with that tool. I will love to make a glass corner window with frameless!

Ditto lets see some advanced planar glass tools in default Archicad.

Re: CORNER WINDOWS - Survey

TomWaltz — Tue, 26 Jun 2007 20:54:28 GMT

nats wrote:
It does seem ridiculous that there are different libraries for different countries when we in the UK get Archicad with log wall types. I mean how many times will I be using that particular construction? In fact I wonder how many times anyone in the USA uses log walls!??

They're ridiculous in the US too. I think like 2 people use it. I suspect it's something that they made back in the 90's and just kept around for laughs. You could do the same thing with the profiled walls, just not as automated.

What do you mean my "planar glass"? Like a storefront? Or something more elaborate?