topic Re: Custom Stairs in Modeling

Custom Stairs

Anonymous — Thu, 25 May 2023 14:51:08 GMT

Hi All,

I am trying to build this stair with stair maker.. I understand that it is a custom stair and although I know I can make this with two stairs or with slabs and other things, I would really like it just to be a single stair that I can edit, throw balustrades on, change materiality and so on.

Basically, when I select the fill and the line of travel I get the the following error message:
'cannot generate stair with this line of travel'
Which would be fine if I were trying to build something really wacky, but this stair is really quite straightforward, so I don't know what the deal is.

Please help?

Thanks,
Nick.

Re: Custom Stairs

Anonymous — Tue, 05 Jul 2011 01:35:31 GMT

Hi Nick,

Try widening the gap between the two flights. ArchiCAD has a problem if they are too close!

Also make sure you are using individual lines and not a polyline to define the line of travel, although it will warn you about this in the error message so I guess you have done this bit correctly.

Re: Custom Stairs

Anonymous — Tue, 05 Jul 2011 02:48:06 GMT

Perfect.. so now it works.. ish.. However, if I widen the gap enough to allow ArchiCAD to build a custom stair, it tries to throw a tread in the space.
This stops me from having treads any wider than 140mm (the dimension I've widened the space to) which makes this a non-compliant stair. I have no wish to have a full 250mm tread in this space as I am trying to create a compact stair in an awkward configuration.

Am I wasting my time? is this going to be possible or should I just do it with two stairs. If so, is it possible to make balustrades connect to each other on two different stairs?

Re: Custom Stairs

Anonymous — Thu, 11 Sep 2014 16:51:50 GMT

Hi,

I'm having the same kind of problem. Reading the previous posts, as a test, I have stretched the hatch and lines to make the central hole larger or to make that left turn a bit longer but AC keeps giving me this error message "cannot generate stair with this line of travel."

Is this kind of stair too complicated for AC to handle?

Re: Custom Stairs

Anonymous — Thu, 11 Sep 2014 23:33:56 GMT

Benjaminmeyer wrote:
Hi,
....AC keeps giving me this error message "cannot generate stair with this line of travel."

This was posted for many times. If you just make a search.
However, the line of travel CAN NOT BE made with ARCS or POLYLINES, only LINES!!!

Re: Custom Stairs

Anonymous — Fri, 12 Sep 2014 09:07:35 GMT

Thanks but I have read the posts on this subject.
I know about not using polylines but what do you mean "no arcs"? What if I want a turn with no landing? What about those posts about the ellipsoid stair? The walking line was made of arcs!

Re: Custom Stairs

Hmooslechner — Thu, 18 Sep 2014 12:33:39 GMT

It is always possible to construct it the old way like on Paper and then use the drawings for 3D-slabs to make the Stair.

german tutorial:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_k7FXzhRea4