You have one single Schedule with two different renovation states?
If that's the case I presume it's also causing your problem.
I'd suggest you make a copy of this Schedule and then edit both Scheme settings - add a Renovation Status Criteria line, one with "New", the other with "Existing" Value. For each Schedule one dedicated Renovation Status value, not both in one. Then you'd have to place two different Schedules into your layout.
That should solve your problem.
| Archicad 4.55 - 27
| HP Z840 | 2× E5-2643 v4 | 64 GB RAM | Quadro M5000 | Windows 10 Pro x64
| HP Z4 G4 | W-2245 | 64 GB RAM | RTX A4000 | Windows 11