cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
EN
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Wall editing tool to trim top part

KevinJ
Booster

Often I need to create some kind of wall which will be trimmed on the top part in diagonal. For example a wall along stairs ... 
To do so there is several approach :
- Create a roof and trim with roof and hide roof or 
- Create a roof and crop 
- Create a morph from wall but it lost some editing possibility (and morph editing is messy)
- Create a special profile in 2D
- Solid element operation and then hide operator element

They are all taking time and need to create other component to arrived to such result.
After all there are already several way to create wall with different thickness for example but this is only for the 2D plan.   
I which there would be a fast way to do the same "vertically", editing wall height at both end of the wall :

KevinJ_1-1752744646910.png

 

7 Comments
Barry Kelly
Moderator

Another option for your list - 

- Add a polygon opening.

 

Barry.

ArchiProject
Booster

It's really time for this feature to be implemented. Drawing a wall with a variable height is more common than it might seem. It's frustrating to always have to rely on workarounds. I believe it should be fairly simple — just allow the possibility to assign different heights to the start and end points of each segment.

Barry Kelly
Moderator

Yes, it would be nice to easily adjust start and end heights for both the top and base of the wall.

You would think it would be possible given that we can already have different start and end widths as well as top and base widths.

But I am sure it is much more complicated with connection to other elements.

 

Barry.

ArchiProject
Booster

Yeah, maybe it's not as easy as it sounds, after all. But i think it's worth considering anyway.

rakurs
Advocate

It might be complicated with complex profiles but I think it is all solvable with "lowest common denominator" type of solution. I think that keeping end height until all junctions resolve, and rise or fall from there would be a rather simple solution to such a problem. If you need more freedom than that, you can always use SEO. But for the vast majority of situations, it would solve many problems and reduce the number of steps and workarounds.

Giuliano Di Guida
Participant

I agree that it is absolutely essential to implement this feature. Drawing a wall with a variable height is very common in the day-to-day workflow in the construction industry. It is frustrating, and it wastes a great deal of time and productivity to always have to resort to workarounds. I don’t think it should be that complicated to implement by adding the option to assign different heights to the start and end points of each segment, given that this is already possible for width and slope. I wonder why no one has ever thought of this feature for walls before, as I find it both natural and essential for carrying out the work.

Botonis
Mentor

This is the reason to merge the wall and beams into one element that share the same options and capabilities, both in 2d and 3d.

Even the connection priority behaviour in certain cases is different between those two element types.

Walls seem more flexible while beams create anomalies even when there is no slanting or edge angles.

 

Also the wall projection without the 2d fills is another limitation.

 

Status
Submitted

with 29 Votes

Wish details
Product
Labels