cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Advanced Zone Tool with Editable 3D Top Surface (Mesh‑like, with Slopes and Vertical Steps)

nonpertutti
Booster

Managing Zones under sloped or irregular ceilings is currently cumbersome. Adjusting Zone heights requires splitting Zones, creating multiple elements, or using manual cuts, which complicates reporting and introduces errors.

 

We propose evolving the Zone tool to support a Mesh‑like editable top surface, with both sloped surfaces and vertical steps, similar to how real ceilings often behave (e.g., dropped ceilings, beam offsets).

 

Key capabilities:

 

  • Node-based editing: Add nodes and set different heights, just like with Meshes, to model irregular ceiling shapes directly within a single Zone.
  • Vertical steps: At the same point in plan view, define sudden height changes (like steps or drops), not only gradual slopes—essential for accurately modeling suspended ceilings, soffits, or split-level interiors.
  • Multiple display modes:
    • 3D realistic mode: Shows true sloped and stepped geometry.
    • Conceptual planar mode: Flat top with automatic average height calculation (Volume / Area).
  • Detailed data extraction: Automatically obtain:
    • Area and volume for each sloped or stepped portion,
    • Minimum, maximum, and average heights,
    • All accessible in labels, schedules, and expressions.
  •  
  • Zone types: Keep current flat Zones for simple spaces; add advanced Zones with editable top surfaces for complex spaces.

 

 

Why this is useful:

 

  • Simplifies modeling of spaces under complex roofs or ceilings, including sloped and stepped areas, without multiple Zones or cuts.
  • Ensures accurate area and volume calculations in reports and schedules.
  • Improves documentation: in plan view, display divisions of ceiling heights and slopes automatically.
  • Similar improvements would also benefit the Mesh tool itself, which currently lacks true step handling within a single surface.
4 Comments
nonpertutti
Booster

@Karel Landa there we are 🤓

 

Karel Landa
Graphisoft Partner
Graphisoft Partner

@nonpertutti Nicely written, thanks  

Erik Bjornhage
Advisor

I replied to a similar wish regarding area calculations of zones - perhaps these are related and should be merged?

SeaGeoff
Ace

Zones could do so much more. Returning accurate volumes without a lot manual work is the #1 priority. I would love to see Zones automatically conform to their enclosing elements in all 3 dimensions and have a live update option.

Status
Open

with 16/200 Votes 12.5%

Wish details