2008-10-04 05:45 PM
2008-10-15 11:44 AM
2008-11-09 05:11 PM
2009-05-26 10:10 AM
mikem wrote:Jumping in very late here - I am at this thread because of frustrations with the ArchiCAD / Cinema 4D workflow ... searching hopefully. I am on trials of both. My main targets for C4D are modeling capabilities and rendering - but only with a smooth back and forth with ArchiCAD.
A problem for both Archicad and Vectorworks is the lack of native structural and MEP capabilities that engineers could and would use. Allplan does have the structural capabilities.
If Archicad and AllPlan also switched to Parasolids then maybe this would provide the possibility of a common file format, or a file format that would make exchanging files between the three programs easier. It might also open the door to the sharing of content, and make providing content for the NAG programs a more attractive proposition for suppliers.
A synergy opportunity exists with the three NAG programs. my own view is that working cooperatively will ultimately be more beneficial to all three programs. Going it alone and competing with each other just doesn't seem to make sense.
2009-05-26 05:51 PM
2009-05-26 08:57 PM
2009-05-27 09:34 AM
aswx0 wrote:Agreed one hundred percent. Archicad + Allplan (with all its applications!) + VW + C4D is an incredibly stong combo, should they work together and consolidate. I just don't know how to get the message through to Nemetschek AG.
...But I am amazed at how crap the integration is among the Nemetschek products... ... I am a mac user so Revit and the Autodesk options are not for me but if I was on windows I can't see how I could resist.
Nemetschek needs to get some serious consolidation going to make their products work together smoothly. Biplab Sarkar's interview suggests that the VW Parasolid move was VW driven, but I hope there is more to it. Allplan/ArchiCad/Vectorworks is just too fragmented vs the huge and growing Revit base. Not enough content. Not enough of a community.
Let's at least have a route to better interoperability in AC13.
2009-05-27 03:37 PM
2009-05-28 11:05 AM
2009-05-29 02:07 AM
stefan wrote:well really for all practical purposes the C4D Material Exchange plugin is broken atm (it works, just not how anyone needs it to) ... still no ETA on a fix either. Seems the Vectorworks Exchange plugin has been fixed though.
FWIW, regarding Cinema4D, they have (with various success and still many errors) plugins for VectorWorks, ArchiCAD and Allplan to render in Cinema4D.