cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
EN
cancel
Showing results for 
Search instead for 
Did you mean: 
chitecture_x
Contributor

Stairs Landing

Hi All. 
First timer in stair making and YT Videos seem inadequate. 
I want to make a landing on both sides. Is this possible? 

I have attached 2 photos, one with 23 stairs. But want to add a landing to connect it round so i can copy more on upper floors. 
When I activate the pet pallette, and press landing, it adds more stairs. I have turned off auto landing but doesnt work. 

BeforeBefore   After (Trying to add landing to connect to stairs above.)After (Trying to add landing to connect to stairs above.)

 

Operating system used: Windows 11

  

2 Replies 2
runxel
Moderator

That's a very valid use case, that's sadly not really well supported.

Something for @James B to have a look at maybe, for further improvement of this tool.

 

In my experience, if you want to end with a landing: the tool does not really want to let you do that. If you draw from the bottom up (so here starting on the left), then it insists on adding a last step, that does not go away, not even when using the trick of adding treads at the bottom: it will only let you add 2 in this example, thus vanishing the landing alltogether:

 

runxel_0-1778762888703.pngrunxel_1-1778763209201.png

 

However, starting from the top and drawing "backwards" achieves this. This is imho a very stupid workaround; but atleast it works.

 

runxel_2-1778763269304.png

 

 

runxel_3-1778763305690.pngrunxel_4-1778763358883.png

 

This stair can now be shaped as intended. I often first lay out the stair roughly and then fine tune, because otherwise the inputs are not really taken in (tight corners etc.)

Also don't get me started on that you can produce wildly different results that only rely on how the element was laid out initially without being to change that later. So yeah, sometimes you just have to redraw the whole thing; sometimes it also gets bugged internally, from which also no recovery is possible.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Lucas Becker | AC 29 on Mac (Sequoia) | Graphisoft Insider Panelist | Akroter.io – high-end GDL objects | Author of Runxel's Archicad Wiki | Editor at SelfGDL | Developer of the GDL plugin for Sublime Text

My List of AC shortcomings & bugs | I Will Piledrive You If You Mention AI Again |

POSIWID – The Purpose Of a System Is What It Does /// «Furthermore, I consider that Carth... yearly releases must be destroyed»
Kumar Jo
Participant

I was able to get it with default US template, WE and here this what I did. I use TOP (physical top of stair) and BOTTOM (physical bottom of stair) instead of UP and DOWN which sometime confuses with how we set the floor plan display.

1. Draw the stair, the settings are in the screenshot, I turned off the auto landing and locked in the tread depth to 1'. Rest are just default.

2. Stretch the stair (using reference) at the top to the depth of landing required

3. Added a node at the point where the stair reaches in the step 1.

4. Declare the last segment (@top) as landing.

5. Use stretch with reference line option and push back to the the level where it reaches the top floor.

This worked every time with both End w Tread and End w Riser. Also, everything is exactly as said by @runxel .

 

KumarJo_0-1778782864035.png

 

|| AC 29 || Windows 11 32GB ||
|| PNY nVIDIA 4060Ti 16GB XLR8||

Still looking?

Browse more topics

Back to forum

See latest solutions

Accepted solutions

Start a new discussion!