Modeling
About Archicad's design tools, element connections, modeling concepts, etc.

Problem with the height of the land

Anonymous
Not applicable
I have some troubles to drop the land's height, i put in the details of my land, around 173000 in height,
Wat i did is, i go to 'view'--> 'element 3d view'--> 3d cutting place' draw a line trough the land, then activate '3d cut way'. I can see the height of my land is dropped in 'Generic perspective' but not in the 'elevations'. what steps am i missing?

PS: i heard that i have to go 'design'-->'story settings' to change some settings, if so, what kind of settings i have to change there?
Anyone can give me a help?

tn_11.JPG
10 REPLIES 10
Anonymous
Not applicable
You don't really need your land model to extend all the way to sea level do you? Why not just model the part near the surface? I find anywhere from 3-10m below the lowest point is generally enough.

The 3D cutting planes only affect the 3D window and views derived from that. Section/elevations are separate and each have a setting for top and bottom of the section cut.

Story settings, though related, have little to do with this.
Anonymous
Not applicable
I do this all the time. It is alot easier to model the mesh when the elevation figures you enter are the actual levels, no need for doing maths in my head..
The way I get around this problem is follows:

1. Build the mesh as you have done using actual levels.
2. Now trace the mesh with a 100mm thick slab that is positioned about a metre below the lowest point on the mesh. Make the slab the same material and section fill as the mesh you are using.
3. Use Solid Element Operations to subtract with downwards extrusion using the slab as an operator and the mesh as the target.

This method will cut off the bottom of the mesh just like the 3D cutting plane, but will show correctly in both 3D and sections.
Anonymous
Not applicable
I just set a sea level reference and model and edit the mesh relative to that rather than the mesh reference plane. There's no advantage as far as I can see to justify fussing with the sections/3D cutting planes nor the SEOs.
Anonymous
Not applicable
Matthew is quite right you can simply insert a negative number in the dialog box (see picture) this will chop off some of the bottom.

If the land mesh is placed on the same storey as your floor slab you should position it's height releative so to place the SL=0 of the mesh at 0.

In your case if your storey is set to match a floor slab at 173m. The mesh should be placed at -173000 and you could put -150000 in the box I mentioned. This would place the mesh in the correct relative position with the bottom 150m missing.
MESH.jpg
Anonymous
Not applicable
Thanks for help guys!
Anonymous
Not applicable
Brewer wrote:
Matthew is quite right you can simply insert a negative number in the dialog box (see picture) this will chop off some of the bottom.

If the land mesh is placed on the same storey as your floor slab you should position it's height releative so to place the SL=0 of the mesh at 0.

In your case if your storey is set to match a floor slab at 173m. The mesh should be placed at -173000 and you could put -150000 in the box I mentioned. This would place the mesh in the correct relative position with the bottom 150m missing.
This is a neat trick also but not quite what I meant. If you set one of the two reference levels to sea level (relative to project zero - see attached) then you can simply adjust the mesh elevations relative to that reference level.

This saves having to do the somewhat counterintuitive negative thickness and eliminates the need for a sea level story height. In fact it separates the whole issue from story settings altogether.
Reference Levels.jpg
Anonymous
Not applicable
Here is the mesh settings dialog showing the height to sea level option.
Mesh Settings.jpg
Anonymous
Not applicable
...and here is the dialog for setting the contour height relative to sea level. No story settings involved.
David Shorter
Advisor
Here is my 2 cents
I do not understand reference levels as (it seems to me) to increase the likelihood of error
It frustrates me that the info box and some of the other dialogues do not show the same values.
I have never really understand why you wouldn't work to real levels
It makes things very simple
Archicad 4.1 to 28 Tech Preview. Apple Silicon
you can't build a line
Mac Studio
iPad Pro
iPhone