2 weeks ago
Hello,
I'm having trouble with Solid Element Operations (SEO).
I have two walls. The upper wall is an exterior façade wall, and its top and bottom are in contact with two roofs (not shown). The lower wall is an interior wall separating two areas with roofs at different heights. The blue mesh is an SEO operator that will be hidden.
What I want is for the top of the lower wall to be trimmed by the blue mesh, while the bottom of the upper wall to also trimmed by the same mesh.
The problem is that, after performing the SEO operation, the upper wall also cuts its own volume out of the lower wall. This is not caused by SEO, because the two walls do not have any SEO relationship with each other. It appears to be a building material priority issue.
Both walls need to remain on the same layer. Their composite structures are similar: the upper wall uses the same composite as the lower wall, with a few additional layers on the exterior side.
What can I do to make the walls intersect correctly, so that the upper wall is not automatically subtracted from the lower wall?
Thank you in advance.
Operating system used: Windows
Solved! Go to Solution.
2 weeks ago
why do they need to be on the same layer? I have several "non-intersecting" layers for instances just like this:
A-Wall - group 1
A-Wall.non-intersecting - group 2
A-Trim - group 1
A-Trim.non-intersectiong - group 2
A-Wall.Foundation - group 3
...
it's more to manage in the layer combos, but it's the best method I've found for: barge to fascia, stair skirt to base board, dormer walls to exterior walls, etc. etc.
2 weeks ago
You can have each of the walls in a separate layer with a different intersection number for those layers.
2 weeks ago
Thank you, Mathias. That's what I'll eventually do if no other solution comes up. I know it would solve the issue; I just don't want to create a separate layer just for that wall. Also, changing the intersection priority of a layer that contains other elements would affect those elements as well, and I'd rather avoid that.
On the back side, both walls in my example are coplanar and have the same finish. Using this method would create a line separating them, even though there shouldn't be one.
2 weeks ago
why do they need to be on the same layer? I have several "non-intersecting" layers for instances just like this:
A-Wall - group 1
A-Wall.non-intersecting - group 2
A-Trim - group 1
A-Trim.non-intersectiong - group 2
A-Wall.Foundation - group 3
...
it's more to manage in the layer combos, but it's the best method I've found for: barge to fascia, stair skirt to base board, dormer walls to exterior walls, etc. etc.
2 weeks ago
Did not think that walls overlapping each other trimmed each other? I cannot figure out how to get them to do that anyway...
What are your settings that you get a line between coplanar elements that use the same surface? There are a lot of posts around asking for this. Is it some new setting that I have missed?
Ling.
| AC22-29 AUS 3200 | Help Those Help You - Add a Signature |
| Self-taught, bend it till it breaks | Creating a Thread |
| Win11 | i9 10850K | 64GB | RX6600 | Win11 | 7800X3D | 32GB | RTX5070TI |
2 weeks ago
Hello. I dont get that line between them. It is what I thaught would happen, becouse the walls would be in layers with different intersection numbers. It turns out I was wrong. The layers didnt matter. There was no line. Sorry for not clarrifying this earlier.