Modeling
About Archicad's design tools, element connections, modeling concepts, etc.

Going back to Revit vs Archicad

Anonymous
Not applicable
I am working on Revit since 2003 ( version 5.0), it is easy to see that ArchiCad is way in front. compability they will tell you... Thanks to Revit version 9.0, now it is easier to <translate> your work in Autocad, for <the others>. Anyway, Autodesk's product are compatible with each other only in <our minds> they are selling you < Autodesk >

Can somebody tell me if ArchiCad 10 is supported by the new Apple-Intel Technology and the new OSx ? So I can switch now.
22 REPLIES 22
TomWaltz
Participant
sylvain wrote:
I am working on Revit since 2003 ( version 5.0), it is easy to see that ArchiCad is way in front. compability they will tell you... Thanks to Revit version 9.0, now it is easier to <translate> your work in Autocad, for <the others>. Anyway, Autodesk's product are compatible with each other only in <our minds> they are selling you < Autodesk >

Can somebody tell me if ArchiCad 10 is supported by the new Apple-Intel Technology and the new OSx ? So I can switch now.
AC9 and the original AC10 release do not support MacIntel at all. There is an Archicad 10 MacIntel version in testing currently. My reseller tells me it's due in July.

If you are running Windows on the MacIntel, I understand the Windows version of AC10 runs quite well.
Tom Waltz
Anonymous
Not applicable
TomWaltz wrote:
AC9 and the original AC10 release do not support MacIntel at all. There is an Archicad 10 MacIntel version in testing currently. My reseller tells me it's due in July.

If you are running Windows on the MacIntel, I understand the Windows version of AC10 runs quite well.
While not officially supported, AC9 and 10 both run quite well under Rosetta (10 is a bit slower but I am using it with no difficulty for real work). I can recall only two crashes with AC10 on my MacBook Pro and none in AC9. I am constrained from reporting about the Mactel beta - but I think it's safe for me to say that you have nothing to worry about.

And, yes, both versions run well in WinXP on the Mactel.
David Larrew
Booster
Speaking of Revit...

I just went to the latest Autodesk marketing show for Revit 9. Revit has come a long way since it's introduction. But it still has a way to go to match ArchiCAD as a complete solution package.

I did notice some nice new features that Revit 9 now has that I'd really like ArchiCAD to implement. One big feature is their "obscure element option" for 3D detailing (for showing hidden lines). Revit also seems to handle the automatic sheet drawing references much better than AC (more automatic - less set-up/work).

If anyone thinks that "Teamwork" is a hard to use... Try sharing a project file in Revit - talk about a nightmare! The presenters even had to do some back-peddling to defend the logic.
David Larrew, AIA, GDLA, GSRC

Architectural Technology Specialist

a r c h i S O L U T I O N S



WIN7-10/ OSX 10.15.7

AC 5.1-25 USA
Rakela Raul
Participant
great info david, cmon man, share some more !!
MACBKPro /32GiG / 240SSD
AC V6 to V18 - RVT V11 to V16
Anonymous
Not applicable
I went recently to a <smoke show> of Archicad. Unfortunately it was a disaster too. I downloaded a student version last week ( is there any real demo available ?) to get through it because I was very discouraged, I realized that day that I have learned so much just by my interest in Archicad... My advice to you is <BE-CARE-FULL>; those guys are not working with the package, they are only selling it. It is very bad, I am a Revit user, I know that Archicad is way in front but the marketing is not efficient at all. I had money in my pocket that day, it never went out...I am still going through the <student version> for my evaluation... the software is awesome. REMEMBER, ASK A USER. The TEAMWORK is called WORKSETS in Revit; it is like punching in and out of determined <work area>, (components can be assign to a specific workset) and it is very efficient when you need extra visibility control while your on your own.(solo no sharing). When you shared your model to other user you can assign specific areas to specific users. You can shared everything to everyone too. Let's say I am using the ext. shell workset and you are using the int. one. If you move a wall and your wall interfere with <my> window (because the windows have been set to the ext.shell workset, let's say) you will need to move the window, right. Once you will pick the window and try to move it, you will be informed by Revit that I am working on the ext.shell and you will have to ask me the permission to move it. Yep...You won't be able to move it until I give you the permission to do it. So built in Revit there is a communication system between user to control those <changes from above>. Looks good you will say, imagine that you are waiting for my permission and I am in the bathroom...Patience my friend. Teamwork in Archicad looks easier and more logical. Anyway, I am very anxious to switch to Archicad...
Anonymous
Not applicable
"sylvain" wrote:
I went recently to a <smoke show> of Archicad. Unfortunately it was a disaster too.
C'mon give the guys a break. There is a lot to learn with this one, If your show was a disaster it was probably due to just being so new in the market. Typically the dealers don't get their hands on it till a week before it's release.
Anonymous
Not applicable
sylvain wrote:
Patience my friend. Teamwork in Archicad looks easier and more logical. Anyway, I am very anxious to switch to Archicad...
In Teamwork one can marquee an empty space not associated with the model and not have to reserve a layer or ask permissions... just send and receive. The existing model can not be edited with this method...but I like that especially if it is ready to embellish w/ dims and notes.
Anonymous
Not applicable
Interesting thread. Resellers often don't know software as well as their users so sales presentations are often 'crash and burn' sessions! (Have done a few of those myself where ignorance was not the culprit as much as badly behaving hardware.)

Having not used Teamwork -- and not completely understanding how it works -- perhaps someone would like to describe how it works to an AC alumni user (me). Esp with regards to all the files that are interacting on the workstation, and the server.

With regards to Revit: sylvain is correct. All Revit files start as single user files. Clicking the worksets button creates worksets in the current open file; the next save after this creates the central file. You copy the central file to your hard drive; that's the local file. You work on the local file, and click the "Save to Central" button to update the central file and get updates in the central file that you don't have.

Worksets that contain 3D objects are named by the user -- Exterior shell, Interior Partitions, Structure, etc. When a user selects an object -- wall, dimension, whatever -- Revit immediately contacts the central file to see if the object is available, if so you can edit it, if not, it tells you who's got it signed out and you can at that point ask them to hand over control through the Editing Requests dialog box.

Worksets aren't hard -- it's the collaborative process that has all these indepedent CAD users unglued. You have to work together, and sometimes people don't like that.

As for files, there's the local and central files, and that's it. On megaprojects you can link files together but walls from linked files don't clean up with walls in the host file. So you got us beat there 😉

If someone wouldn't mind doing a desktop share over the phone one day, we could have a good look at each other's software and take notes, and report back to the users with what we find. A lot of the information circulating on these (and AUGIs forums) is because the posters don't really know how The Other Program works. So I'd prefer to talk to a knowledgable AC user -- no resellers! I'm currently working on contract for a number of parties -- including the reseller in my sig, so I'm only interested in getting and giving the straight goods.

Any takers? I got some huuuuge projects I could show, and some midsize projects too.
Anonymous
Not applicable
One thing that amazes me is how AutoCad guys are committed to Autodesk. They want to switch to BIM software so they don't even look around but go for Revit, even though that Revit is far more different from AutoCad than other BIM packages (AC, ARC+, TriForma). This is amazing considering that they did not wanted to switch to BIM before because of those differences. Even communication between Revit and Autocad suck. Is it real commitment or pure marketing magic ?